Evangelical Catholic Church (Independent)
Independent Catholic body merging Catholic heritage/sacraments with LGBTQ affirmation; outside Roman jurisdiction.
How close are your beliefs to Evangelical Catholic Church (Independent)?Statement-by-statement likeness, from your quiz answers.
Full belief profile
Grouped by topic, in plain language. These are tradition-level defaults; individual congregations can and do differ.
God & the Trinity16 positions · 11 held strongly
A personal God who is the creator and sustainer of all things truly exists, independent of human belief.
Strongly affirmsThe Son is of the very same essence (consubstantial) as the Father, not merely of a similar essence.
Strongly affirmsThere is exactly one God, numerically a single divine being.
Strongly affirmsFather, Son, and Spirit are genuinely distinct persons, not merely three modes, masks, or roles of a single person.
Strongly affirmsThe one God exists eternally as three distinct persons: Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.
Strongly affirmsGod is an immaterial spirit, without a physical body of any kind.
Strongly affirmsLove is essential to who God is in himself, grounded in the eternal love among the persons of the Trinity, not merely something God does toward creatures.
Strongly affirmsGod genuinely hears and responds to petitionary prayer, sometimes acting differently than he otherwise would have.
Strongly affirmsGod is omnipotent: able to do anything that is logically possible and consistent with his nature.
Strongly affirmsGod is fully present everywhere in his being, not merely in knowledge or power.
Strongly affirmsGod knows all true propositions, including all of the actual past and present, exhaustively.
Strongly affirmsGod infallibly and exhaustively knows the entire future, including all future free choices, as settled certainties.
AffirmsGod transcends gender entirely, so feminine images and language for God (e.g. God as Mother) are as fitting as masculine ones.
AffirmsGod genuinely suffers and is moved with grief and compassion in response to creaturely suffering and sin.
AffirmsGod experiences temporal succession: there is a real before-and-after in God's own life and knowledge.
AffirmsGod's wrath against sin is a real and proper disposition of his holy character, not merely a metaphor or an absence of relationship.
RejectsChrist21 positions · 17 held strongly
Jesus rose bodily in the same (transformed) body that was crucified.
Strongly affirmsJesus committed no sin during his life.
Strongly affirmsRight relationship with God comes specifically through Jesus Christ and not through any other name/mediator.
Strongly affirmsFather, Son, and Spirit are one single person manifesting in three modes or roles.
Strongly rejectsJesus had a complete, real human body of flesh.
Strongly affirmsDeity and humanity are united in one single person (hypostasis) in Christ.
Strongly affirmsThe New Testament directly identifies Jesus as "God" (e.g. John 1:1; 20:28; Titus 2:13).
Strongly affirmsJesus Christ is identified with the LORD (YHWH) of Israel.
Strongly affirmsThe Son was created/originated by God and is therefore a creature, however exalted.
Strongly rejectsThe Son is a distinct divine person from the Father (not merely a mode or role of one person).
Strongly affirmsThe Son is "of the same essence" (homoousios) as the Father, not merely of a similar essence.
Strongly affirmsJesus Christ is fully and truly God, sharing the one divine essence with the Father.
Strongly affirmsThe Son existed as a divine person before his human birth, prior to and apart from creation.
Strongly affirmsJesus is rightly given the worship due to God.
Strongly affirmsThere was a state or "time" in which the Son did not exist.
Strongly rejectsAfter the incarnation Christ exists "in two natures," divine and human, each retaining its own properties.
Strongly affirmsJesus was conceived by the Holy Spirit in the Virgin Mary, without a human father.
Strongly affirmsMary may rightly be called "Theotokos" (God-bearer / Mother of God) because the one she bore is God.
AffirmsThe titles given to Jesus ("Lord," "Son of God," "Word") connote true deity, not merely a high human office.
RejectsThe union of divine and human in Christ occurred at the moment of conception, not at a later point such as baptism.
RejectsThe Son remains permanently incarnate: he retains a glorified human nature forever.
No firm positionSin & the fall13 positions · 8 held strongly
There was a real, primeval historical event ("the Fall") in which the first humans disobeyed God and lost an original state of integrity.
Strongly affirmsThe Genesis Fall narrative is best read as a symbolic or mythic depiction of the universal human condition, not a report of a singular past event.
Strongly rejectsAdam and Eve were real, historical individuals from whom humanity descends.
Strongly affirmsSatan is a real, personal spiritual being who tempts and opposes God, not merely a symbol or personification of evil.
Strongly affirmsPhysical death entered the human race as a consequence of Adam's sin; humans were not originally subject to death.
Strongly affirmsAdam's first sin has real, inherited consequences for all his descendants (an "original sin"), not merely a bad example.
Strongly affirmsAfter the Fall sin is so deep that it has become the very substance/essence of fallen human nature.
Strongly rejectsSin is fundamentally the transgression of God's law/command (an offense against a divine standard).
Strongly affirmsMoral evil arises necessarily from the gift of genuine creaturely free will, which God could not give without the possibility of its misuse.
AffirmsThe root of all sin is pride / inordinate self-love (turning from God to self).
AffirmsProperly speaking, something counts as sin only if it is voluntary (chosen knowingly and willingly).
AffirmsSin is most fundamentally a rupture of relationship/covenant with God and neighbor, more than law-breaking or substance-corruption.
Leans toward affirmingNo one in this life (apart from special exception) is wholly free from sin; the regenerate continue to sin.
Leans toward affirmingSalvation14 positions · 2 held strongly
The finally unsaved suffer conscious punishment in hell that never ends.
Strongly affirmsJustification is a forensic, declarative act in which God legally pronounces the sinner righteous, distinct from the inner process of being made holy.
Strongly affirmsOn the cross Christ bore the penalty/punishment that sinners deserved, satisfying God's justice in their place (penal substitution).
RejectsSalvation is fundamentally a lifelong process of being saved rather than a single completed event.
AffirmsThe righteousness by which a believer is justified is Christ's own righteousness credited/imputed to them, external to and not produced by the believer.
RejectsSalvation is accomplished by God alone working in the person (monergism); the human will does not cooperate in the new birth.
RejectsA believer can have a settled present assurance that they are saved.
Leans toward affirmingGood works/holiness are necessary not merely as evidence but as a real condition of final salvation.
Leans toward affirmingA person is justified by faith alone (sola fide), apart from any contribution of their works to the ground of justification.
Leans toward rejectingSaving faith necessarily includes submission to Christ as Lord and a commitment to repent/obey, not mere intellectual assent.
Leans toward rejectingBaptism is a symbol/ordinance that publicly signifies a salvation already received by faith and does not itself convey saving grace.
No firm positionA person who is genuinely saved can never lose their salvation ("once saved, always saved").
No firm positionRepentance (a real turning from sin) is required for salvation.
No firm positionA genuine believer can fall away and forfeit salvation (apostasy / conditional security).
No firm positionThe Holy Spirit17 positions · 9 held strongly
God is one indivisible person who manifests successively or simultaneously as Father, Son, and Spirit, rather than three eternally distinct persons.
Strongly rejectsThe Spirit is a distinct hypostasis/person, genuinely other than the Father and the Son, not merely a mode or aspect of the one God.
Strongly affirmsThe Holy Spirit is eternal, without beginning, and shares the one uncreated divine nature.
Strongly affirmsThe Holy Spirit is the divine author who inspired the writers of Scripture.
Strongly affirmsThe Holy Spirit is fully and truly God, equal in divine essence to the Father and the Son.
Strongly affirmsThe Holy Spirit is a distinct personal agent (who can be grieved, speaks, wills, and intercedes), not merely an impersonal force or energy.
Strongly affirmsThe Spirit works savingly in people who are outside the visible institutional church, including beyond explicit Christian profession.
Strongly affirmsThere is a specific sin against the Holy Spirit that is unforgivable.
Strongly affirmsThe Spirit so guides the Church's official teaching that it can be preserved from error (infallibility) on matters of faith.
Strongly rejectsThe Spirit's saving, regenerating grace is ultimately irresistible in those God has chosen.
RejectsThe fruit of the Spirit (love, joy, peace, etc.) is the truest evidence of the Spirit's presence, more than the spectacular gifts.
AffirmsThe Spirit distributes gifts sovereignly as He wills, so believers cannot simply claim or work up a particular gift.
AffirmsBeing "filled with the Spirit" is a repeatable, commanded experience distinct from the one-time indwelling.
Leans toward rejectingBy the Spirit, a believer may reach a state of entire freedom from conscious/willful sin in this life.
Leans toward rejectingBaptism in/with the Holy Spirit happens at conversion and is identical with becoming a Christian: not a separate later event.
Leans toward affirmingSpirit-baptism is primarily for power/empowerment for witness and service, distinct from the saving work that makes one a believer.
Leans toward rejectingThe Spirit "seals" the believer as a permanent guarantee of final salvation that cannot be undone.
No firm positionThe Church16 positions · 12 held strongly
The bishop of Rome (the pope) holds a divinely instituted primacy of jurisdiction over the whole church.
Strongly rejectsThe church is apostolic: it must stand in genuine continuity with the apostles' teaching and mission.
Strongly affirmsThe church is the mystical Body of Christ, organically united to him as its head.
Strongly affirmsThe church is catholic (universal): the whole company of Christ's people across all times and places, not confined to one nation, culture, or congregation.
Strongly affirmsThe church is a divine institution founded by Christ, not merely a voluntary human association of like-minded believers.
Strongly affirmsThe church is holy (set apart and sanctified by Christ) even though its members remain sinners.
Strongly affirmsThe true church is essentially ONE (a single body) despite outward divisions.
Strongly affirmsBelonging to the visible, organized church is normally necessary for the Christian life, not an optional add-on to private faith.
Strongly affirmsThe church's central mission is to proclaim the gospel and make disciples (the Great Commission as its defining task).
Strongly affirmsThe pope, under defined conditions (ex cathedra, on faith and morals), teaches infallibly.
Strongly rejectsThe church should formally practice corrective discipline, up to exclusion, against unrepentant serious sin among members.
Strongly affirmsLocal churches are properly bound together under a wider connectional structure (conference, synod, communion) with real authority over them.
Strongly affirmsIn this age the visible church is a mixed body containing both genuine believers and the unregenerate (wheat and tares, sheep and goats together until the end).
AffirmsEvery believer is a priest with direct access to God, with no need for a mediating human priest.
AffirmsThe institutional church is a provisional, this-age reality that will give way to the consummated Kingdom, rather than itself being the final goal.
AffirmsScripture is the sole final authority for the church's faith and practice (sola scriptura); all other authorities are subordinate and fallible.
RejectsSacraments & ordinances9 positions · 4 held strongly
There are exactly two ordinances/sacraments instituted by Christ: baptism and the Lord's Supper.
Strongly affirmsThere are seven sacraments: baptism, confirmation/chrismation, Eucharist, penance, anointing of the sick, holy orders, and matrimony.
Strongly rejectsThe mode of baptism (immersion, pouring, or sprinkling) is a matter of indifference and does not affect validity.
Strongly affirmsValid baptism must use the Trinitarian formula "in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit."
Strongly affirmsValid baptism requires full immersion of the body in water.
RejectsSacraments function chiefly to confirm, seal, and strengthen a faith already given, rather than to originate grace.
AffirmsThe Supper is purely a memorial; the bread and wine remain only symbols that prompt remembrance, with no presence or reception of Christ.
Leans toward affirmingBaptism and the Supper are primarily acts of human obedience and public testimony rather than channels of divine grace.
Leans toward rejectingChrist is truly and really present in the bread and wine of the Supper, not merely symbolized.
Leans toward affirmingWorship & liturgy6 positions
The outward form and style of worship is largely a matter of indifference (adiaphora) to be decided by culture, pastoral wisdom, or preference.
AffirmsA primary purpose of the worship service is evangelism and calling outsiders to conversion.
RejectsWorship should be deliberately shaped to feel familiar and accessible to outsiders and the unchurched.
AffirmsThe collection of tithes and offerings is itself an act of worship within the service.
Leans toward affirmingThe Lord's Supper should be celebrated every Lord's Day.
Leans toward affirmingContemporary worship music (CCM, praise-and-worship bands, modern choruses) is fitting and desirable for the gathered church.
No firm positionLast things11 positions · 8 held strongly
Jesus Christ will return personally, visibly, and bodily to the earth at a future point in history.
Strongly affirmsAt death the believer's soul consciously enters the presence of Christ and remains aware while awaiting the bodily resurrection.
Strongly affirmsA specific future seven-year period of unprecedented tribulation (often tied to Daniel's seventieth week) remains to be fulfilled.
Strongly rejectsThe finally unrepentant suffer conscious punishment in hell that continues without end.
Strongly affirmsThe prophecies of Daniel and Revelation should be read primarily as literal predictions of still-future events.
Strongly rejectsThe thousand-year reign of Christ (Revelation 20) denotes a literal, future, earthly period of roughly a thousand years.
Strongly rejectsThere is no distinct "rapture" doctrine at all; the New Testament describes one return of Christ at which the living and the dead are gathered together.
Strongly affirmsChrist's return could occur at any moment, with no remaining prophecy that must be fulfilled first.
Strongly rejectsChrist returns bodily before the millennial kingdom and personally inaugurates it on earth.
RejectsIdentifiable signs (wars, earthquakes, gospel preached to all nations, rise of deception) will mark the approach of the end and can be discerned.
RejectsChrist's return will be accompanied by literal cosmic upheaval: darkened sun, falling stars, and visible glory seen by all.
RejectsScripture7 positions · 7 held strongly
Scripture is the sole infallible rule of faith and practice for the Church.
Strongly affirmsThe canon of Scripture consists of exactly the 66 books of the Protestant Bible.
Strongly affirmsThe historical narratives of Scripture (e.g., the exodus, the conquest, the bodily resurrection) record events that actually happened in space and time.
Strongly affirmsInspiration extends to the actual words of the original text, not only to the general ideas or concepts.
Strongly affirmsThe Holy Spirit is properly called the divine author of Scripture.
Strongly affirmsAll parts of Scripture are equally inspired, not merely the doctrinally central or "religious" portions.
Strongly affirmsThe Christian Scriptures originated through a genuine act of God, not merely human religious reflection.
Strongly affirmsRevelation, creation & science9 positions · 8 held strongly
God created the universe out of nothing (ex nihilo), not from pre-existing matter.
Strongly affirmsGod genuinely reveals something of himself through the natural world and the created order, apart from Scripture.
Strongly affirmsAdam and Eve were real, historical individuals, the literal first human beings.
Strongly affirmsThe fall of humanity into sin was a real historical event by the first humans, not merely a symbol of the universal human condition.
Strongly affirmsGod can and does act in the world in ways that supersede or suspend ordinary natural causes (genuine miracles are possible).
Strongly affirmsWhatever knowledge of God nature provides is insufficient for salvation; saving knowledge requires special revelation in Christ and Scripture.
Strongly affirmsA clear and reliable knowledge of God and his saving purposes requires God's special, verbal self-revelation, not merely general revelation.
Strongly affirmsGenesis 1-3 is intended as an account of actual historical events, not primarily as theological symbol, poetry, or myth.
Strongly affirmsGod still performs miracles today (healings, signs, answered prayer beyond natural explanation) as he did in biblical times.
RejectsLife & bioethics16 positions · 7 held strongly
Abortion is morally permissible when continuing the pregnancy would directly threaten the mother's life.
Strongly affirmsHuman life possesses a special, inviolable dignity because human beings are made in the image of God.
Strongly affirmsThe direct, intentional killing of an innocent human being is always gravely wrong, with no exceptions.
Strongly affirmsHuman life is a gift over which we are stewards, not owners; we may not dispose of it (our own or another's) at will.
Strongly affirmsNon-abortifacient contraception (barrier/hormonal methods that prevent fertilization) is morally acceptable for married couples.
Strongly affirmsAbortion is impermissible in all circumstances, including rape, incest, fetal anomaly, and threat to the mother's life.
Strongly rejectsUsing lethal force to defend oneself or others from a deadly attacker is morally permissible.
Strongly affirmsThe state may, in principle, justly impose the death penalty for the gravest crimes.
RejectsDonating one's organs after death is a morally good and praiseworthy act of charity.
AffirmsDeliberately ending a pregnancy by killing the unborn is in itself a grave moral wrong.
RejectsA competent adult's autonomy over their own body is the decisive moral consideration in life-and-death medical choices.
AffirmsDeliberately ending a patient's life to relieve suffering (active euthanasia) is always morally wrong.
RejectsA distinct human person, bearing full moral status, exists from the moment of conception/fertilization.
RejectsWhen a life involves sufficient suffering or loss of function, considerations of "quality of life" can outweigh the duty to preserve it.
AffirmsA physician may permissibly help a competent, terminally ill patient end their own life at the patient's request.
Leans toward affirmingSuicide (taking one's own life) is morally wrong.
No firm positionSexuality & marriage12 positions · 6 held strongly
The church should liturgically bless and solemnize same-sex unions.
Strongly affirmsChristians who experience exclusive same-sex attraction are called to lifelong celibacy or to a mixed-orientation marriage with the opposite sex.
Strongly rejectsBy definition and divine design, marriage is the union of one man and one woman.
Strongly rejectsSexual acts between two people of the same sex are always morally wrong.
Strongly rejectsSame-sex sexual attraction is an objective disorder of desire even when not acted upon.
Strongly rejectsA covenanted union between two people of the same sex can be a true marriage in God's sight.
Strongly affirmsA person's sex is a fixed, binary, God-given reality determined at conception, not something that can be changed.
RejectsOne's stance and conduct on sexual ethics bears on salvation/standing before God, not merely on discipleship maturity.
RejectsSexual sins are not categorically graver than other sins and should not be singled out for special emphasis or discipline.
AffirmsPremarital sex (fornication) is always sinful, even between an engaged or committed couple.
RejectsScripture provides binding, authoritative norms for sexual conduct that the church is not free to revise.
RejectsSexual intercourse is morally reserved exclusively for marriage.
Leans toward rejectingSociety & politics10 positions · 5 held strongly
The gospel is essentially a message of individual reconciliation with God, and social transformation is at most a secondary by-product, not part of its core content.
Strongly rejectsRacism (partiality and contempt on the basis of race or ethnicity) is a sin contrary to the gospel.
Strongly affirmsScripture's command to welcome the foreigner and care for the sojourner imposes a real Christian duty toward immigrants and refugees today. (This question does not consider any political orientation's specific definition of what constitutes a legitimate "immigrant" or "refugee.")
Strongly affirmsCivil government is divinely instituted, and obedience to lawful authority is a Christian duty (Romans 13).
Strongly affirmsIt can be morally legitimate for Christians to use lethal force under some circumstances (e.g. defense of the innocent, just war).
Strongly affirmsActive civic participation (voting, advocacy, holding office) is a positive Christian duty in a free society.
AffirmsChrist's lordship extends over every sphere of life (politics, economics, art, science) and Christians are called to bring all of them under his rule.
AffirmsIt is fitting for Christians to seek and hold civil office in order to govern justly.
AffirmsOpposing abortion and protecting unborn life should be among the highest priorities of Christian political engagement.
AffirmsScripture provides binding, authoritative norms not only for personal conduct but for the ordering of society, economics, and the state.
AffirmsAngels & demons10 positions · 10 held strongly
Beliefs about angels and demons should be limited to what Scripture plainly teaches, rejecting speculative hierarchies, named extra-biblical angels, and elaborate demonologies.
Strongly affirmsAngels are created beings, made by God, and are not eternal or self-existent.
Strongly affirmsBiblical "angels" are best understood as symbols, personifications, or mythological language for God's action and human experience, not as actually existing spirit-persons.
Strongly rejectsAngels are real, personal, created beings who actually exist, not merely literary symbols or pre-scientific imagery.
Strongly affirmsDemons are real, personal evil spirits (fallen angels or their kind), not merely symbols of disease, vice, or social evil.
Strongly affirmsThe devil and his angels will suffer eternal, conscious punishment in the lake of fire.
Strongly affirmsThe traditional ninefold scheme of angelic orders (seraphim, cherubim, thrones, dominions, virtues, powers, principalities, archangels, angels) reflects a real heavenly order.
Strongly rejectsSatan is a fallen angel (a created good being who rebelled) not an independent evil principle or co-eternal power.
Strongly affirmsSatan/the devil is a real, personal spirit-being, not merely a symbol or personification of evil.
Strongly affirmsA portion of the angels rebelled against God and fell from their original state.
Strongly affirmsAnthropology4 positions · 4 held strongly
Adam and Eve were real, historical individuals who are the biological ancestors of all humanity.
Strongly affirmsHuman beings are created in the image of God.
Strongly affirmsHuman beings inherit a corrupted nature (original sin) from Adam, prior to and apart from any actual sins they commit.
Strongly affirmsThe human soul is by nature immortal and continues to exist consciously after the death of the body.
Strongly affirmsMary & the saints7 positions · 6 held strongly
There is exactly one mediator between God and humanity (Jesus Christ) and no creature shares in that mediating office.
Strongly affirmsMary was preserved free from the stain of original sin from the very first moment of her own conception.
Strongly rejectsMary now reigns as Queen of Heaven, crowned and exalted above all the angels and saints.
Strongly rejectsJesus was conceived by the Holy Spirit while Mary was a virgin, without a human father.
Strongly affirmsIt is good and proper to ask the saints in heaven to pray to God on our behalf.
Strongly rejectsMary remained a virgin throughout her whole life and never had marital relations or other children after Jesus ("ever-virgin").
Strongly rejectsMary may rightly be called "Theotokos" / "Mother of God" (God-bearer) because the one she bore is truly God incarnate.
AffirmsPositions are tradition-level defaults drawn from public confessional documents and reference works; individual congregations can and do differ. Comparison is about distance, not better or worse.
Study deeper
Well-regarded tools for going past summaries and into the sources themselves.