Tradition profile

Brazilian Catholic Apostolic Church (Duarte Costa lineage)

Founded 1945 by ex-Roman bishop Carlos Duarte Costa, rejecting papal authority, celibacy, divorce ban; seeds progressive independent Catholic jurisdictions in the US.

How close are your beliefs to Brazilian Catholic Apostolic Church (Duarte Costa lineage)?Statement-by-statement likeness, from your quiz answers.

Full belief profile

Grouped by topic, in plain language. These are tradition-level defaults; individual congregations can and do differ.

God & the Trinity59 positions · 52 held strongly

Human language about God is analogical: true but never capturing God univocally as it captures creatures.

Strongly affirms

The Son is the first and highest created being, brought into existence by the Father before all else, and therefore had a beginning.

Strongly rejects

God exists from himself (a se), depending on nothing outside himself for his being or his perfections.

Strongly affirms

The Godhead consists of two divine persons (Father and Son), with the Holy Spirit not being a distinct third person.

Strongly rejects

God is best described as the simple, immutable, impassible, timeless, pure-act being of classical theism.

Strongly affirms

God created the world with its laws and now largely refrains from intervening; the world runs on its own.

Strongly rejects

God was entirely free to create or not create; creation adds nothing to and is not necessary for God's perfection or happiness.

Strongly affirms

Moral goodness is ultimately grounded in God's own nature, so the good is not independent of God nor merely arbitrary divine command.

Strongly affirms

God is metaphysically simple: without parts, and identical with his own attributes (God does not "have" goodness, God IS goodness).

Strongly affirms

The Son is eternally begotten of the Father: a timeless, necessary relation, not an event in time.

Strongly affirms

The persons are distinguished only by their eternal relations of origin (the Father unbegotten, the Son begotten, the Spirit proceeding), not by any difference in nature.

Strongly affirms

God infallibly and exhaustively knows the entire future, including all future free choices, as settled certainties.

Strongly affirms

The Holy Spirit proceeds eternally from the Father AND the Son (the Filioque).

Strongly affirms

A personal God who is the creator and sustainer of all things truly exists, independent of human belief.

Strongly affirms

God is an immaterial spirit, without a physical body of any kind.

Strongly affirms

Love is essential to who God is in himself, grounded in the eternal love among the persons of the Trinity, not merely something God does toward creatures.

Strongly affirms

God's existence and some of his attributes can be known with confidence by unaided human reason apart from special revelation.

Strongly affirms

God is pure actuality with no unrealized potential: never moving from potential to actual.

Strongly affirms

God genuinely hears and responds to petitionary prayer, sometimes acting differently than he otherwise would have.

Strongly affirms

The Father is an exalted being who once lived a mortal life and progressed to godhood, and humans can likewise progress toward divinity.

Strongly rejects

The Son is of the very same essence (consubstantial) as the Father, not merely of a similar essence.

Strongly affirms

God's essential nature, character, and purposes never change.

Strongly affirms

God does not suffer or experience emotional change caused by creatures; his "emotions" in Scripture are analogical, not literal passions.

Strongly affirms

The external works of God (creation, providence, salvation) are works of the whole Trinity acting inseparably, distinguished only by appropriation to a person.

Strongly affirms

The divine essence shared by the three persons is one numerically identical essence, not three instances of a common kind.

Strongly affirms

God is omnipotent: able to do anything that is logically possible and consistent with his nature.

Strongly affirms

God is fully present everywhere in his being, not merely in knowledge or power.

Strongly affirms

God knows all true propositions, including all of the actual past and present, exhaustively.

Strongly affirms

There is exactly one God, numerically a single divine being.

Strongly affirms

"Father," "Son," and "Holy Spirit" name three successive or simultaneous manifestations of one indivisible divine person, not three persons.

Strongly rejects

The Son is genuinely lesser than the Father in being or rank, not merely in origin or role.

Strongly rejects

God and the totality of the universe are identical; "God" is just another name for the whole of reality.

Strongly rejects

The three persons mutually indwell and interpenetrate one another (perichoresis/circumincession) so fully that each is in the others.

Strongly affirms

Father, Son, and Spirit are genuinely distinct persons, not merely three modes, masks, or roles of a single person.

Strongly affirms

There exist or may exist other true gods, even if humans worship and are accountable to one God (a plurality/henotheism).

Strongly rejects

God ordinarily works through real secondary causes (natural laws, human agency) rather than acting directly, without those secondary causes being mere illusions.

Strongly affirms

God and the world are mutually dependent and evolving together; God has a changing "consequent" nature shaped by the world and works by persuasion, not coercion.

Strongly rejects

Using the correct Hebrew form of the divine name (and of the Son's name) is important or required for proper worship and right relationship with God.

Strongly rejects

The Holy Spirit is God's active power or influence, not a distinct divine person.

Strongly rejects

God undergoes no real change whatsoever, even in his relation to the world; what changes is the creature, not God.

Strongly affirms

The three persons are fully equal in deity, power, and glory, with no person greater or lesser than another in being.

Strongly affirms

God exists wholly outside of time, in a timeless "eternal now," with no before or after in his own being.

Strongly affirms

God is one being who eternally exists as three co-equal, co-eternal persons (Father, Son, and Holy Spirit) sharing one undivided essence.

Strongly affirms

The one God exists eternally as three distinct persons: Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.

Strongly affirms

Father, Son, and Spirit are best understood as three distinct divine beings or gods who are united in will and love.

Strongly rejects

God is a single divine person (the Father), and the Son and Spirit are not coequal divine persons of the one God.

Strongly rejects

Every creaturely act is simultaneously fully the creature's own act and fully caused by God concurring as primary cause through the creature as secondary cause.

Strongly affirms

God knows all things by knowing his own essence (as the cause and exemplar of all), not by observing the world.

Strongly affirms

God genuinely suffers and is moved with grief and compassion in response to creaturely suffering and sin.

Strongly rejects

God's holiness (his transcendent moral purity and otherness) is the controlling attribute that orders all the others.

Strongly affirms

God sovereignly ordains and governs every event that occurs, down to the smallest detail, so that nothing happens outside his specific will.

Strongly affirms

The world exists within God (all is "in God"), so God includes and transcends the world rather than being wholly separate from it.

Strongly rejects

A real distinction must be drawn between God's unknowable essence and his knowable, participable energies/operations.

Rejects

God merely permits moral evil (does not cause or render it certain), allowing creatures to act against his will.

Affirms

It is right to distinguish God's decretive will (what he sovereignly brings to pass) from his preceptive will (what he commands), and to speak of God "permitting" evils he does not approve.

Affirms

God knows, prior to his creative decree, what any free creature WOULD freely do in any possible circumstance (counterfactuals of creaturely freedom).

Rejects

The Father is the single source/principle (monarchia) of the Son and Spirit within the Godhead.

Rejects

What God is in himself is ultimately beyond human comprehension, so negative ("God is not...") statements are more reliable than positive ones.

Leans toward affirming

The Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father THROUGH the Son (per Filium), a formula distinct from both "and the Son" and "from the Father alone."

Leans toward affirming
Christ73 positions · 69 held strongly

Christ assumed a fully fallen human nature (subject to the effects of the Fall) in order to heal it from within.

Strongly rejects

Christ assumed an unfallen, sinless human nature, untouched by original sin/corruption.

Strongly affirms

"Only-begotten" (monogenēs) means the Son was brought into existence/created.

Strongly rejects

Jesus rose bodily in the same (transformed) body that was crucified.

Strongly affirms

The divine takes flesh in many figures across history; Jesus is one such manifestation among others.

Strongly rejects

The heavenly "Christ"/divine power descended on the man Jesus temporarily (e.g. at baptism) and departed before the crucifixion.

Strongly rejects

Christ "pre-existed" only in God's plan/idea, not as an actual personal being before his birth.

Strongly rejects

Christ is personally and really present in the Eucharist (however explained), not merely symbolically.

Strongly affirms

The Son remains permanently incarnate: he retains a glorified human nature forever.

Strongly affirms

Christ was not able to sin (impeccable): sinning was metaphysically impossible for him.

Strongly affirms

Jesus committed no sin during his life.

Strongly affirms

The properties of each nature may be truly predicated of the one person (e.g. "God suffered," "the man is omnipresent in his person").

Strongly affirms

The "Christ" is a cosmic principle or consciousness distinct from the historical man Jesus.

Strongly rejects

After his death Christ "descended" to the realm of the dead (Hades/Sheol), as the creed affirms.

Strongly affirms

The divine nature underwent no change or loss in the incarnation; God remained fully himself.

Strongly affirms

In Christ the divine Word took the place of a human rational mind/spirit.

Strongly rejects

The Son is eternally "begotten" of the Father: eternally generated, without beginning.

Strongly affirms

The second person is eternally the Son: his Sonship is not merely acquired at the incarnation.

Strongly affirms

When Scripture says "the Father is greater than I," this refers only to Christ's incarnate/economic state, not his divine nature.

Strongly affirms

Father, Son, and Spirit are one single person manifesting in three modes or roles.

Strongly rejects

Material flesh is inherently corrupt, so a truly divine Christ could not assume real flesh.

Strongly rejects

Jesus genuinely experienced human limitation: hunger, fatigue, suffering, growth.

Strongly affirms

Jesus had a complete, real human body of flesh.

Strongly affirms

Jesus possessed a complete human soul/mind, not merely a human body animated by the divine Word.

Strongly affirms

Christ's body only seemed physical; he did not truly have material flesh.

Strongly rejects

Christ's humanity was absorbed into or swallowed up by his divinity, so the human nature does not fully persist.

Strongly rejects

Christ's human will freely and always submitted to his divine will, never opposing it.

Strongly affirms

Deity and humanity are united in one single person (hypostasis) in Christ.

Strongly affirms

Jesus was a man who became/was adopted as God's Son (e.g. at baptism, resurrection, or exaltation) rather than being the Son by eternal nature.

Strongly rejects

The New Testament directly identifies Jesus as "God" (e.g. John 1:1; 20:28; Titus 2:13).

Strongly affirms

Whatever divine status Jesus has was conferred/exalted by the Father after his earthly life, not possessed eternally.

Strongly rejects

Jesus Christ is identified with the LORD (YHWH) of Israel.

Strongly affirms

Jesus is best understood as the supreme prophet/teacher and moral exemplar, not as God incarnate.

Strongly rejects

Jesus was not actually crucified and killed; another was substituted or he was taken up beforehand.

Strongly rejects

In the incarnation the Son actually surrendered or set aside divine attributes (e.g. omniscience, omnipotence).

Strongly rejects

Mary should be called "Christ-bearer" (Christotokos) but not "God-bearer," since she bore the man united to God.

Strongly rejects

Mary may rightly be called "Theotokos" (God-bearer / Mother of God) because the one she bore is God.

Strongly affirms

In the union the two natures are joined without mixture, confusion, or blending into a third kind of thing.

Strongly affirms

Everything Christ did and suffered is attributable to the one divine person of the Son as the single acting subject.

Strongly affirms

Christ has only a single will.

Strongly rejects

Christ's resurrection was spiritual (a spirit being / changed essence) rather than a raising of his physical body.

Strongly rejects

The Son was created/originated by God and is therefore a creature, however exalted.

Strongly rejects

All things were created through the Son (he is the agent of creation).

Strongly affirms

The Son is a distinct divine person from the Father (not merely a mode or role of one person).

Strongly affirms

The Son is of a similar but not identical essence to the Father.

Strongly rejects

The Son is "of the same essence" (homoousios) as the Father, not merely of a similar essence.

Strongly affirms

Jesus Christ is fully and truly God, sharing the one divine essence with the Father.

Strongly affirms

The Son existed as a divine person before his human birth, prior to and apart from creation.

Strongly affirms

Jesus is rightly given the worship due to God.

Strongly affirms

The Son is essentially/ontologically subordinate to the Father (lesser in being, not merely in role).

Strongly rejects

There was a state or "time" in which the Son did not exist.

Strongly rejects

The titles given to Jesus ("Lord," "Son of God," "Word") connote true deity, not merely a high human office.

Strongly affirms

After the incarnation Christ exists "in two natures," divine and human, each retaining its own properties.

Strongly affirms

In Christ there are two distinct persons/subjects (the divine Son and the human Jesus) conjoined in will and honor.

Strongly rejects

Christ has two wills (a divine will and a human will) corresponding to his two natures.

Strongly affirms

The union of divine and human in Christ occurred at the moment of conception, not at a later point such as baptism.

Strongly affirms

The virgin conception is an essential, non-negotiable article of the faith.

Strongly affirms

Jesus was conceived by the Holy Spirit in the Virgin Mary, without a human father.

Strongly affirms

Divine attributes (e.g. omnipresence) are genuinely communicated to Christ's human nature itself, not merely to his person.

Strongly rejects

Even during his earthly life Christ's human soul enjoyed the beatific vision / immediate knowledge of God.

Strongly affirms

"Descended into hell" means Christ endured the torments of hell / the Father's wrath (whether on the cross or in the grave).

Strongly rejects

In the descent Christ proclaimed victory / liberated the righteous dead (the "harrowing of hell").

Strongly affirms

The eternal Son, even while incarnate, continues to exist and act also beyond the limits of his human body ("the Word is not confined to the flesh").

Strongly affirms

Right relationship with God comes specifically through Jesus Christ and not through any other name/mediator.

Strongly affirms

In becoming human the Son "emptied himself" by veiling or not independently using certain divine prerogatives, while remaining fully God.

Strongly affirms

Christ's miracles flowed from his own intrinsic divine power, not solely as a man empowered by the Father/Spirit.

Strongly affirms

After the union there is one incarnate nature of the Word, in which divinity and humanity are united without separation, confusion, or change.

Strongly rejects

Jesus' divine sonship and works are best explained by the Holy Spirit's presence and empowerment rather than by a pre-existent divine nature.

Strongly rejects

Christ has two natures and two hypostases (qnome) united in one prosopon/parsopa, without becoming two separate persons.

Strongly rejects

During his earthly life Christ lived by faith and trust, not by constant possession of comprehensive divine knowledge.

Rejects

Christ's human body can be present everywhere (ubiquitous), grounding his bodily presence in the Lord's Supper.

Rejects

In his human nature Christ had genuinely limited knowledge and could grow in understanding.

Rejects

The Son is subordinate to the Father in role/authority even while equal in divine essence.

Rejects
Sin & the fall64 positions · 37 held strongly

Before God all sins are fundamentally equal: there are no greater or lesser sins.

Strongly rejects

Infants who die are (at least the elect among them) certainly saved by Christ apart from any work or profession of their own.

Strongly affirms

Evil is a real, independent principle or power, in some sense co-eternal with or independent of the good God.

Strongly rejects

Evil and sin have no genuine reality; they are errors of perception or illusion to be dispelled by truth.

Strongly rejects

Evil has no positive substance of its own; it is a privation or corruption of good (evil = the lack of a due good).

Strongly affirms

God is in no way the author or cause of sin, even while sovereign over all things.

Strongly affirms

The Virgin Mary was, by special grace, preserved free from original sin from the moment of her conception (Immaculate Conception).

Strongly affirms

Some sins are "mortal" (gravely severing the soul from grace/eternal life) while others are "venial" (wounding but not destroying the relationship with God).

Strongly affirms

Humans can live righteously and attain salvation by free will and effort without a special interior grace beyond creation, law, and example.

Strongly rejects

Adam's first sin has real, inherited consequences for all his descendants (an "original sin"), not merely a bad example.

Strongly affirms

The guilt of original sin is truly removed/remitted by baptism (concupiscence may remain, but the guilt is taken away).

Strongly affirms

Before the Fall, humanity possessed an original righteousness / supernatural endowment of grace and integrity that was subsequently lost.

Strongly affirms

Satan is a real, personal spiritual being who tempts and opposes God, not merely a symbol or personification of evil.

Strongly affirms

After the Fall sin is so deep that it has become the very substance/essence of fallen human nature.

Strongly rejects

Sins genuinely differ in heinousness and in the degree of guilt and punishment they incur.

Strongly affirms

Physical death entered the human race as a consequence of Adam's sin; humans were not originally subject to death.

Strongly affirms

The justified believer is at once righteous (in Christ) and still a sinner (in himself): simul iustus et peccator.

Strongly rejects

Concupiscence (the inclination/desire to sin) is itself truly sin, even when not consented to.

Strongly rejects

The mere inclination toward sin is not sin until the will consents; only consented acts/dispositions are culpable.

Strongly affirms

Disordered desire (concupiscence) remains in the baptized/regenerate even after original sin's guilt is removed.

Strongly affirms

All people have an innate moral conscience/knowledge of God's law (written on the heart), so none sin in total ignorance.

Strongly affirms

Moral evil arises necessarily from the gift of genuine creaturely free will, which God could not give without the possibility of its misuse.

Strongly affirms

Moral evil entered creation first through the prideful fall of angels (Satan/the devil) prior to humanity's fall.

Strongly affirms

There was a real, primeval historical event ("the Fall") in which the first humans disobeyed God and lost an original state of integrity.

Strongly affirms

Even without saving grace, the unregenerate can perform genuine civic/external good (justice, kindness) that is truly good on its own level.

Strongly affirms

Adam and Eve were real, historical individuals from whom humanity descends.

Strongly affirms

The image of God in humanity, though damaged by sin, is genuinely retained and is the basis of human dignity and capacity for relationship with God.

Strongly affirms

Infants are born already in a state of original sin (corruption and/or guilt), not in moral neutrality.

Strongly affirms

Original sin consists essentially in the loss/privation of original righteousness (a lack), rather than a positively infused evil.

Strongly affirms

Original sin is transmitted to each person through natural generation (by being descended from Adam), not by imitation.

Strongly affirms

Sins committed deliberately/high-handedly are more culpable than sins of weakness, ignorance, or passion.

Strongly affirms

The root of all sin is pride / inordinate self-love (turning from God to self).

Strongly affirms

No one in this life (apart from special exception) is wholly free from sin; the regenerate continue to sin.

Strongly affirms

Each human soul is created immediately by God at conception, not propagated from the parents.

Strongly affirms

The soul is propagated from the parents along with the body (traducianism), which helps explain how a sinful nature is inherited.

Strongly rejects

A person can take the first step toward God (the initial desire or seeking of faith) by free will, with grace then assisting thereafter.

Strongly rejects

There is a sin (blasphemy against the Holy Spirit) that will not be forgiven, in this age or the next.

Strongly affirms

Every sin, however small, deserves God's condemnation/death: there is no class of sin that does not by nature merit it.

Rejects

Apart from grace, even the apparent virtues of the unregenerate are, before God, sinful ("splendid vices").

Rejects

Sin is not only personal but takes corporate/structural forms: unjust systems, institutions, and "principalities" that embody and perpetuate evil.

Affirms

Adam's sin disordered not only humanity but the wider created order (a "cosmic fall" affecting nature itself).

Affirms

The Genesis Fall narrative is best read as a symbolic or mythic depiction of the universal human condition, not a report of a singular past event.

Rejects

The Fall, though evil, was a "happy fault" because it occasioned a greater good (the incarnation and redemption) than would otherwise have been.

Affirms

Humanity was created immature and the "Fall" was part of a developmental ascent toward maturity rather than a catastrophic loss.

Rejects

All humans descend biologically from a single original couple (monogenism), not from a population.

Affirms

Human beings are by nature fundamentally good, and wrongdoing is chiefly the result of ignorance, environment, or unmet needs rather than an inner corruption.

Rejects

Infants are born morally innocent and become guilty only by their own actual sins once capable of moral choice.

Rejects

The Fall corrupted the will and affections most deeply, while the intellect/reason retained substantial soundness.

Affirms

Sin is fundamentally the transgression of God's law/command (an offense against a divine standard).

Affirms

Properly speaking, something counts as sin only if it is voluntary (chosen knowingly and willingly).

Affirms

"Structural sin" is ultimately reducible to the sum of individual personal sins and has no independent reality.

Affirms

In the fallen state, a person is unable to turn to God or do saving good without a prior, enabling work of divine grace.

Affirms

The "unforgivable sin" is best understood as persistent, final impenitence/rejection of grace until death, not a single past utterance.

Affirms

Believers can, by grace, reach a state in this life in which they are freed from all willful/known sin (Christian perfection / entire sanctification).

Rejects

The transmission and locus of original sin is especially bound up with sexual concupiscence/generation (sin is propagated through the disordered act of generation).

Rejects

The Fall and the entrance of sin fell within God's eternal decree/permission (God ordained to permit it for greater ends).

Affirms

Involuntary sinful thoughts or desires that arise without consent can be genuinely sinful and require repentance.

Rejects

We were really, seminally present "in Adam" and so truly participated in his sin (realist/seminal solidarity).

Rejects

Sin is most fundamentally a rupture of relationship/covenant with God and neighbor, more than law-breaking or substance-corruption.

Affirms

Sin has corrupted every part of human nature (mind, will, affections, body) so that no faculty is left untouched ("total" in extent, not necessarily in degree).

Rejects

Infants who die unbaptized are, because of original sin, deprived of the beatific vision (whatever their further state).

Rejects

Adam was the appointed representative (federal head) of humanity, so his sin is imputed to us by covenant/representation, apart from our seminal presence in him.

Leans toward rejecting

All humans bear actual guilt for Adam's sin: they are culpable before God on account of it, prior to any personal act.

Leans toward affirming

The fundamental sin is unbelief (failure to trust God's word) from which other sins flow.

Leans toward rejecting
Salvation76 positions · 55 held strongly

Baptism is a symbol/ordinance that publicly signifies a salvation already received by faith and does not itself convey saving grace.

Strongly rejects

Baptism itself effects regeneration / the washing away of sin, conferring saving grace through the act.

Strongly affirms

Baptism is valid only when received by a person old enough to personally profess faith.

Strongly rejects

The good works a believer does in grace genuinely merit an increase of grace and eternal reward before God.

Strongly affirms

A person who is genuinely saved can never lose their salvation ("once saved, always saved").

Strongly rejects

The Lord's Supper / Eucharist conveys real saving or sustaining grace to the worthy recipient, not merely a memorial.

Strongly affirms

Both faith and good works (cooperating with grace) are jointly necessary as the means by which one is finally justified before God.

Strongly affirms

God genuinely desires the salvation of every single person without exception.

Strongly affirms

Good works/holiness are necessary not merely as evidence but as a real condition of final salvation.

Strongly affirms

Saving grace is a created, habitual quality infused into the soul that elevates and heals it.

Strongly affirms

It is right to baptize the infants/children of believers (or of the faithful community).

Strongly affirms

Justification admits of degrees and can increase through subsequent works and the sacraments.

Strongly affirms

Justification is a forensic, declarative act in which God legally pronounces the sinner righteous, distinct from the inner process of being made holy.

Strongly rejects

Justification is fundamentally a real inner transformation (the infusing of righteousness that actually makes a person righteous) not just a verdict.

Strongly affirms

A person is justified by faith alone (sola fide), apart from any contribution of their works to the ground of justification.

Strongly rejects

Someone who has fallen from grace can repent and be restored to salvation.

Strongly affirms

New birth requires the full sequence of repentance, water baptism in the name of "Jesus" (not the Trinitarian formula), and the baptism of the Holy Spirit evidenced by speaking in tongues.

Strongly rejects

Prayers, Masses, or almsgiving by the living can benefit the salvific state of the dead.

Strongly affirms

After death, many of the saved undergo a purifying state ("purgatory") before entering full glory.

Strongly affirms

Repentance (a real turning from sin) is required for salvation.

Strongly affirms

The righteousness of justification is infused into and becomes intrinsic to the believer, growing as they cooperate with grace.

Strongly affirms

The righteousness by which a believer is justified is Christ's own righteousness credited/imputed to them, external to and not produced by the believer.

Strongly rejects

A person is incorporated into salvation chiefly through the Church's sacraments of initiation (baptism, confirmation/chrismation, Eucharist) rather than a personal decision.

Strongly affirms

God ordinarily dispenses saving grace through material sacraments/mysteries as effective channels.

Strongly affirms

A rightly performed sacrament conveys its grace by the very fact of being performed (ex opere operato), not depending on the worthiness of the minister or recipient's merit.

Strongly affirms

A genuine believer can fall away and forfeit salvation (apostasy / conditional security).

Strongly affirms

The Church can apply the superabundant merits of Christ and the saints (the "treasury of merit") to remit temporal punishment, e.g. through indulgences.

Strongly affirms

Christ's lifelong law-keeping (his "active obedience"), not only his death, is imputed to the believer as their positive righteousness.

Strongly rejects

The finally lost are ultimately destroyed/cease to exist rather than suffering everlasting conscious torment (annihilationism / conditional immortality).

Strongly rejects

Assurance rests on Christ's finished work and God's promise, not on the believer's own works or sacramental performance.

Strongly rejects

A believer can have a settled present assurance that they are saved.

Strongly rejects

Christ died to actually secure the salvation of the elect specifically (limited/definite/particular atonement), not equally for all persons.

Strongly rejects

Christ died for all people without exception, making salvation available to everyone (unlimited/general atonement).

Strongly affirms

Water baptism is ordinarily necessary for salvation; one is not normally saved apart from it.

Strongly affirms

Salvation is received by making a deliberate personal decision for Christ (e.g. praying to receive him / answering an altar call).

Strongly rejects

God actively predestines some to salvation and others to damnation (double predestination).

Strongly rejects

Who is among the elect cannot be known with certainty in this life.

Strongly affirms

The finally unsaved suffer conscious punishment in hell that never ends.

Strongly affirms

A future/final justification will be rendered "according to" the whole life lived in the Spirit, not on the basis of present faith alone.

Strongly affirms

Human beings retain, even after the fall, a natural ability to take the first step toward God or to choose salvation without prior special grace.

Strongly rejects

People who never explicitly hear of Christ can nevertheless be saved through Christ on the basis of responding to the grace/light they have.

Strongly affirms

Justification is a single, completed, non-repeatable act at the point of faith, not a status that is repeatedly gained and lost.

Strongly rejects

No human work has any merit before God; salvation and reward are entirely of grace.

Strongly rejects

Before any human response, God gives a preceding ("prevenient") grace to all that restores enough ability to freely accept or reject salvation.

Strongly affirms

Other religions are themselves valid, independent paths to God/salvation, not dependent on Christ.

Strongly rejects

God positively/actively decrees the reprobation of the non-elect (not merely "passing them by").

Strongly rejects

Salvation is fundamentally a lifelong process of being saved rather than a single completed event.

Strongly affirms

Salvation is accomplished by God alone working in the person (monergism); the human will does not cooperate in the new birth.

Strongly rejects

Salvation involves a genuine cooperation between God's grace and the human will (synergism).

Strongly affirms

After conversion the believer grows in holiness gradually over a lifetime (progressive sanctification).

Strongly affirms

Christ's death rendered satisfaction to God's offended honor/justice for the debt of sin (Anselmian satisfaction).

Strongly affirms

The human can make the first move toward God (e.g. an initial desire or assent), after which God supplies the grace to complete salvation.

Strongly rejects

The dead are unconscious ("sleep") until the resurrection rather than immediately experiencing reward or punishment.

Strongly rejects

In the end God will reconcile and save all people (and possibly all creatures), so that none are finally lost.

Strongly rejects

Good works are the necessary fruit and evidence of saving faith but contribute nothing to the ground of one's justification.

Strongly rejects

The justified believer remains, throughout life, simultaneously righteous and a sinner (simul justus et peccator).

Rejects

Those whom God calls to salvation are infallibly drawn so that the call cannot finally fail (effectual calling).

Rejects

The atonement is principally Christ's victory over sin, death, and the powers of evil, liberating humanity from bondage.

Affirms

Salvation centers on an identifiable, often datable moment of conversion / being "born again."

Rejects

Conscious, explicit faith in Jesus Christ is necessary for salvation; there is no salvation for those who never come to such faith.

Rejects

When God gives saving grace to the elect, it cannot ultimately be resisted and infallibly accomplishes its purpose.

Rejects

God's saving grace genuinely offered to a person can be resisted and rejected by that person's free will.

Affirms

Grace is the uncreated divine energies of God himself, in which the believer really participates, not a created gift.

Rejects

Saving faith necessarily includes submission to Christ as Lord and a commitment to repent/obey, not mere intellectual assent.

Affirms

Salvation is ordinarily found only within the one true visible Church; to be saved one must belong to it.

Affirms

A believer can reach a state of being free from all actual sin in this life.

Rejects

The goal of salvation is theosis/deification: the believer becoming "partaker of the divine nature," really sharing in God's life.

Affirms

Salvation is best understood as participation/union with Christ, from which both justification and sanctification flow, rather than as a primarily legal transaction.

Affirms

The atonement's deepest purpose is to heal and divinize human nature (joining humanity to God), more than to settle a legal account.

Affirms

Before creation, God predestined particular individuals to salvation.

Affirms

On the cross Christ bore the penalty/punishment that sinners deserved, satisfying God's justice in their place (penal substitution).

Affirms

There is some real cleansing, growth, or change in the soul's condition after death (apart from a juridical "purgatory").

Affirms

Christ saves by "recapitulating": living out and reversing in himself every stage of human life that Adam corrupted, healing human nature from within.

Affirms

Fallen humans are so corrupted that, apart from grace, they are entirely unable to turn to God or choose saving good (total inability).

Affirms

The preached/read Word of God is the primary means by which saving grace is given, with sacraments subordinate or secondary.

Rejects

God's choice of whom to save rests solely on his own will/good pleasure, not conditioned on any foreseen faith, merit, or response in the person.

Leans toward rejecting
The Holy Spirit57 positions · 38 held strongly

Adding "and the Son" to the Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed was a legitimate clarification the whole Church may accept.

Strongly affirms

The Holy Spirit eternally proceeds from the Father AND the Son (filioque).

Strongly affirms

The Spirit's indwelling is conferred chiefly through the sacrament of baptism (and/or chrismation/confirmation).

Strongly affirms

Recognized prophets today can speak with binding, Scripture-level authority over the church.

Strongly rejects

The governing offices of apostle and prophet have been restored and should lead the church today.

Strongly rejects

God is one indivisible person who manifests successively or simultaneously as Father, Son, and Spirit, rather than three eternally distinct persons.

Strongly rejects

Public tongues-speaking in the gathered assembly must be accompanied by interpretation or remain silent.

Strongly affirms

Sanctification is the Spirit's ongoing work in which the believer actively cooperates ("walk by the Spirit").

Strongly affirms

A person genuinely indwelt by the Spirit can lose that indwelling through apostasy or grave sin.

Strongly affirms

The Spirit is a distinct hypostasis/person, genuinely other than the Father and the Son, not merely a mode or aspect of the one God.

Strongly affirms

The new birth (regeneration) is a work the Holy Spirit accomplishes in the believer.

Strongly affirms

The Holy Spirit is eternal, without beginning, and shares the one uncreated divine nature.

Strongly affirms

Ordination/consecration confers a specific charism of the Spirit for church office (priest, bishop, presbyter).

Strongly affirms

The Spirit can be resisted, grieved, and quenched by human beings.

Strongly affirms

The Spirit so guides the Church's official teaching that it can be preserved from error (infallibility) on matters of faith.

Strongly affirms

Any present-day prompting attributed to the Spirit must be tested by and remain subordinate to the written Scripture.

Strongly affirms

The Spirit is of the same essence (homoousios) as the Father and the Son.

Strongly affirms

What Scripture calls "the Holy Spirit" is best understood as God's impersonal power or presence-in-action rather than a third "who."

Strongly rejects

Every true believer is permanently indwelt by the Holy Spirit from the moment of conversion.

Strongly affirms

The Holy Spirit is the divine author who inspired the writers of Scripture.

Strongly affirms

The Holy Spirit is a created being or the highest creature, not eternal and uncreated.

Strongly rejects

The Holy Spirit is fully and truly God, equal in divine essence to the Father and the Son.

Strongly affirms

The Holy Spirit is a distinct personal agent (who can be grieved, speaks, wills, and intercedes), not merely an impersonal force or energy.

Strongly affirms

The Holy Spirit eternally proceeds from the Father.

Strongly affirms

The Spirit authoritatively speaks through the decisions of the Church's councils ("it seemed good to the Holy Spirit and to us").

Strongly affirms

The Spirit is genuinely subordinate to the Father and the Son in rank or authority, not merely distinct in role.

Strongly rejects

The Holy Spirit is rightly worshiped and glorified together with the Father and the Son.

Strongly affirms

Spiritual gifts exist primarily to build up the gathered body, not for individual display or status.

Strongly affirms

Settled assurance of salvation is normal and to be expected for genuine believers in this life.

Strongly rejects

There is a specific sin against the Holy Spirit that is unforgivable.

Strongly affirms

The Spirit's direct inner light within each person is a primary and sufficient source of religious truth and direction.

Strongly rejects

When prayed-for healing does not occur, the usual explanation is insufficient faith on the part of those involved.

Strongly rejects

Regeneration is monergistic: the Spirit gives new life before and apart from any cooperating act of the human will.

Strongly rejects

The Holy Spirit was personally active in the creation of the world.

Strongly affirms

The Spirit is characteristically imparted or stirred up through the laying on of hands.

Strongly affirms

The Spirit can be rightly described as the mutual love or bond (vinculum amoris) between the Father and the Son.

Strongly affirms

The Holy Spirit is essentially the immanent divine presence pervading nature and the cosmos (a world-indwelling Spirit) more than a transcendent personal third.

Strongly rejects

The Spirit "seals" the believer as a permanent guarantee of final salvation that cannot be undone.

Strongly rejects

The Spirit grants a special "anointing" empowering particular individuals for ministry beyond the common indwelling.

Affirms

There is a second, instantaneous work of grace after conversion in which the Spirit purifies the heart from the sin nature (entire sanctification / Christian perfection).

Rejects

The Father alone is the single ultimate cause (monarchia) of the Spirit's eternal origination.

Rejects

The gift of supernatural healing operates through believers today.

Affirms

By the Spirit, a believer may reach a state of entire freedom from conscious/willful sin in this life.

Rejects

Spirit-baptism is primarily for power/empowerment for witness and service, distinct from the saving work that makes one a believer.

Rejects

The Spirit distributes gifts sovereignly as He wills, so believers cannot simply claim or work up a particular gift.

Affirms

The Spirit's saving, regenerating grace is ultimately irresistible in those God has chosen.

Rejects

The Spirit works savingly in people who are outside the visible institutional church, including beyond explicit Christian profession.

Affirms

Casting out demons (deliverance ministry) should be a normal, expected part of the church's ministry today.

Affirms

The fruit of the Spirit (love, joy, peace, etc.) is the truest evidence of the Spirit's presence, more than the spectacular gifts.

Affirms

The miraculous/sign gifts (prophecy, tongues, healings, miracles) ceased with the apostolic age and are not normative today.

Rejects

Baptism in/with the Holy Spirit happens at conversion and is identical with becoming a Christian: not a separate later event.

Affirms

The Spirit gifts and empowers every believer for ministry (priesthood of all believers), not a clerical class alone.

Affirms

The Spirit gives believers a direct inner witness assuring them they are God's children.

Rejects

The Spirit must internally illumine a reader for Scripture to be rightly understood and received as God's word.

Affirms

When exercised genuinely, tongues are real, existing human languages (xenoglossy), not unintelligible utterance.

Rejects

Being "filled with the Spirit" is a repeatable, commanded experience distinct from the one-time indwelling.

Leans toward rejecting

The Spirit proceeds from the Father THROUGH the Son (per Filium), not from the Son as a co-cause.

Leans toward affirming
The Church85 positions · 72 held strongly

A minister's ordination is only VALID if conferred by a bishop standing in apostolic succession.

Strongly affirms

Apostolicity consists primarily in fidelity to apostolic DOCTRINE, not in an unbroken chain of ordinations from the apostles.

Strongly rejects

Baptism is the rite of entry/incorporation into the visible church.

Strongly affirms

The bishop of Rome (the pope) holds a divinely instituted primacy of jurisdiction over the whole church.

Strongly affirms

The one church currently subsists across several "branches" (e.g. Rome, the East, Anglicanism) that are all part of the true church despite separation.

Strongly rejects

An inward call and the recognition of fellow believers is sufficient to minister; formal ordination/credentialing is unnecessary.

Strongly rejects

The baptized children of believers are already members of the visible church/covenant community, not outsiders awaiting conversion.

Strongly affirms

Legitimate teaching and governing authority in the church descends through tactile apostolic succession of bishops.

Strongly affirms

The church is apostolic: it must stand in genuine continuity with the apostles' teaching and mission.

Strongly affirms

The church is the mystical Body of Christ, organically united to him as its head.

Strongly affirms

The church is catholic (universal): the whole company of Christ's people across all times and places, not confined to one nation, culture, or congregation.

Strongly affirms

The church is a divine institution founded by Christ, not merely a voluntary human association of like-minded believers.

Strongly affirms

The church is essentially a single concrete, visible communion; "invisible church" is a misleading abstraction.

Strongly affirms

The church is holy (set apart and sanctified by Christ) even though its members remain sinners.

Strongly affirms

In this age the visible church is a mixed body containing both genuine believers and the unregenerate (wheat and tares, sheep and goats together until the end).

Strongly affirms

Saving grace is normally mediated THROUGH the institutional church and its sacraments, not received apart from it.

Strongly affirms

The true church is essentially ONE (a single body) despite outward divisions.

Strongly affirms

In the New Testament "church" refers primarily to the local visible congregation; the "universal church" is at most a future/heavenly assembly.

Strongly rejects

The gathered membership of the local church is the final human court of authority (decisions rest with the congregation, not clergy or courts).

Strongly rejects

Each local congregation is self-governing and autonomous under Christ, answerable to no higher ecclesiastical authority.

Strongly rejects

Local churches are properly bound together under a wider connectional structure (conference, synod, communion) with real authority over them.

Strongly affirms

The decisions of genuine ecumenical councils are infallible and irreformable for the whole church.

Strongly affirms

The validity/efficacy of sacraments does not depend on the personal holiness of the minister (against Donatism).

Strongly affirms

Government by bishops in apostolic succession is the divinely intended and necessary form of church order (jure divino episcopacy).

Strongly affirms

Lawful excommunication actually binds in heaven: it carries real spiritual consequences, not merely social ones.

Strongly affirms

The true church largely apostatized after the apostolic age and had to be RESTORED in modern times through a new movement/prophet.

Strongly rejects

It is right to share the Eucharist/communion across denominational lines with other believing Christians (open communion).

Strongly rejects

Properly recognized lay persons may lead worship and even administer the sacraments when needed, without ordination.

Strongly rejects

A living teaching office (magisterium) authoritatively and bindingly interprets Scripture and Tradition for the whole church.

Strongly affirms

Church membership should be limited to those who give a credible personal profession of faith (a regenerate/believers' church).

Strongly rejects

Belonging to the visible, organized church is normally necessary for the Christian life, not an optional add-on to private faith.

Strongly affirms

The ordained minister functions as a priest who offers a sacrifice (the Eucharist) on behalf of the people.

Strongly affirms

The church's central mission is to proclaim the gospel and make disciples (the Great Commission as its defining task).

Strongly affirms

There should be no distinct ordained clergy class; all believers minister equally without a separate office of pastor/priest.

Strongly rejects

The church should bind consciences to no creed, confession, or council: "no creed but Christ / the Bible alone."

Strongly rejects

A true church need not practice outward water-baptism or the Lord's Supper at all; the inward reality suffices.

Strongly rejects

Only churches practicing the correct (e.g. believer's-immersion) baptism, in unbroken local succession, are true churches; others are not churches at all.

Strongly rejects

Even granting the priesthood of all believers, an ordained ministry remains a distinct, divinely warranted office, not merely a functional convenience.

Strongly affirms

Ordination confers a sacramental, indelible priestly character empowering the minister to offer the Eucharist and absolve sins.

Strongly affirms

Our own communion IS the one true church Christ founded; others are separated or deficient bodies, not equal branches.

Strongly affirms

The papacy is a later, illegitimate human development: a corruption rather than Christ's design.

Strongly rejects

Any primacy of Rome is at most a primacy of HONOR among equal bishops, not a primacy of governing jurisdiction.

Strongly rejects

In the New Testament "bishop" (episkopos) and "elder" (presbyteros) name the same office; there is no separate higher order of bishop.

Strongly rejects

Christ's commission to Peter ("upon this rock") established a perpetual office continued in the bishops of Rome.

Strongly affirms

The pope, under defined conditions (ex cathedra, on faith and morals), teaches infallibly.

Strongly affirms

A priest, by power conferred in ordination, actually forgives/absolves sins in the sacrament of penance/confession.

Strongly affirms

Scripture is the sole final authority for the church's faith and practice (sola scriptura); all other authorities are subordinate and fallible.

Strongly rejects

The church should be led directly by Spirit-anointed apostles/prophets whose governance carries divine authority over the congregation.

Strongly rejects

The ministry is rightly ordered in three distinct orders (bishop, presbyter/priest, and deacon) as the apostolic pattern.

Strongly affirms

Sacred Tradition stands alongside Scripture as a co-equal source of binding revelation.

Strongly affirms

Christ's true church has existed continuously and visibly in every age since Pentecost, never wholly apostatizing.

Strongly affirms

The church's God-willed unity must be a VISIBLE, institutional, communion-and-sacramental unity, not merely a spiritual bond among believers.

Strongly affirms

The universal church is the primary reality, and local congregations are its parts or outcroppings.

Strongly affirms

The offices of elder/pastor and the authoritative teaching of men in the gathered church are reserved to qualified men.

Strongly affirms

Women may be ordained to the pastoral/priestly office on the same basis as men.

Strongly rejects

The local church's unity and reality are constituted around its bishop celebrating the Eucharist.

Strongly affirms

Direct Spirit-anointing/charisma is a higher source of church authority than ordained office or institutional structure.

Strongly rejects

The church should formally practice corrective discipline, up to exclusion, against unrepentant serious sin among members.

Strongly affirms

The church is the continuation/fulfillment of Israel: the people of God now redefined around Christ (the "Israel of God").

Strongly affirms

The faithful church should remain a distinct, separated community withdrawn from the institutions and entanglements of worldly society.

Strongly rejects

Those in the (higher) ordained ministry should be unmarried/celibate.

Strongly affirms

Church councils and creeds have real authority but may err and remain subordinate to Scripture.

Strongly rejects

Denominations are a legitimate and acceptable expression of Christian diversity, not a scandal to be overcome.

Strongly rejects

The goal of church discipline is the restoration of the offender, not merely punishment or protecting the church's purity.

Strongly affirms

The "real" church is the invisible company of all the elect/truly regenerate, known certainly only to God, of which any visible body is an imperfect expression.

Strongly rejects

A living prophet/president holds the keys of authority and can give the church binding direction today.

Strongly rejects

Working for social justice and the transformation of society is an integral, not optional, part of the church's mission.

Strongly affirms

Christian bodies outside our own communion possess real (if imperfect) grace, valid baptism, and genuine churchly reality.

Strongly affirms

The local church should be led by a plurality of co-equal elders rather than by a single senior pastor or by congregational vote.

Strongly rejects

The church should be governed by presbyters (elders) acting collectively through graded courts (session, presbytery, synod, assembly).

Strongly rejects

Christians are obligated to pursue the visible, organic reunion of the divided churches.

Strongly affirms

The worship and glorification of God (leitourgia) is the church's highest and defining purpose, above mission or fellowship.

Strongly affirms

The church is a "mystery" not foreseen in the Old Testament: a distinct parenthesis begun at Pentecost.

Rejects

The organized ecumenical movement tends toward doctrinal compromise and should be resisted; separation from error is a duty.

Rejects

National/ethnic Israel and the church are two distinct peoples of God with distinct promises; the church has not replaced Israel.

Rejects

There is no salvation outside the (visible) church (extra ecclesiam nulla salus), strictly understood.

Affirms

Members must socially shun/avoid those placed under the ban, including in ordinary daily relations.

Rejects

The institutional church is a provisional, this-age reality that will give way to the consummated Kingdom, rather than itself being the final goal.

Affirms

The church rightly seeks to shape law, culture, and the civil order according to Christian principles (a Christianized society as a goal).

Affirms

God works and dispenses truth/salvation today through ONE specific visible organization, and being rightly related to it is essential.

Rejects

The church should have a defined, formal membership that one joins by a deliberate covenant or profession.

Rejects

Each rightly-gathered local church is fully and not merely partially "the church": the whole church is present where the people gather with the Word and sacraments (or, for some, the Eucharist with the bishop).

Affirms

Every believer is a priest with direct access to God, with no need for a mediating human priest.

Affirms

The church should be institutionally separate from the civil government: no established or state church.

Leans toward rejecting

The true church is identified by the right administration of the sacraments (alongside the right preaching of the Word).

Leans toward affirming
Sacraments & ordinances83 positions · 71 held strongly

Baptism should wait until a person reaches an age of accountability and can repent and believe for themselves.

Strongly rejects

Anointing of the sick with oil is a sacrament conveying grace, healing, and forgiveness to the seriously ill.

Strongly affirms

Baptism by pouring water over the head (affusion) is a fully valid mode.

Strongly affirms

Baptism imprints an indelible spiritual mark/character on the soul that can never be repeated or removed.

Strongly affirms

Baptism is necessary for salvation (ordinarily required to be saved).

Strongly affirms

Those who die unbaptized may still be saved through "baptism of desire" or martyrdom ("baptism of blood").

Strongly affirms

Baptism conveys no grace whatsoever; it is purely a symbolic public testimony of an inward change.

Strongly rejects

Baptism removes the guilt of original sin.

Strongly affirms

Baptism is a sign and seal of grace already promised, not the instrument that produces regeneration.

Strongly rejects

In baptism God regenerates the recipient: the new birth/washing away of sin actually occurs in the rite.

Strongly affirms

Only those who personally profess faith should be baptized; infant baptism is not true baptism.

Strongly rejects

Communicants receive Christ's body orally with the mouth (manducatio oralis), not merely spiritually by faith.

Strongly affirms

Worthy reception of the Supper conveys forgiveness of sins and nourishes the soul unto eternal life.

Strongly affirms

Through anointing with chrism the recipient receives the seal/gift of the Holy Spirit not given in water baptism alone.

Strongly affirms

Confirmation (chrismation) is a distinct sacrament that completes baptismal initiation and imparts the Holy Spirit.

Strongly affirms

Christ's body and blood are truly present "in, with, and under" the bread and wine, which remain bread and wine.

Strongly rejects

The Eucharist/Supper should be the central act of every Lord's Day worship service.

Strongly affirms

The Eucharist makes present (re-presents), without repeating, the one sacrifice of Calvary.

Strongly affirms

The consecrated host may rightly be adored and worshiped as Christ himself.

Strongly affirms

A validly performed sacrament conveys grace by virtue of the act itself (ex opere operato), independent of the worthiness of the minister.

Strongly affirms

There are exactly two ordinances/sacraments instituted by Christ: baptism and the Lord's Supper.

Strongly rejects

Beyond baptism and the Supper, rites like confirmation, penance, orders, marriage, and anointing are "lesser" or "commonly called" sacraments lacking dominical institution.

Strongly rejects

Ordination (holy orders) is a sacrament that confers grace and a permanent character for ministry.

Strongly affirms

Indulgences can remit the temporal punishment due to forgiven sins, drawing on the Church's treasury of merit.

Strongly affirms

Infants and young children of believers should be baptized.

Strongly affirms

For a sacrament to be valid the minister must intend "to do what the Church does."

Strongly affirms

Baptism should be performed in the name of Jesus alone, not with the threefold Trinitarian formula.

Strongly rejects

The dying should receive final sacramental ministrations (final anointing, viaticum, absolution) to prepare the soul for death.

Strongly affirms

Sacraments/ordinances may be administered by any believer, not only by ordained clergy.

Strongly rejects

In an emergency, baptism by a layperson (even a non-believer) is valid.

Strongly affirms

Marriage is a sacred, God-ordained covenant, but it is not a sacrament that conveys grace.

Strongly rejects

The Eucharist is a true and propitiatory sacrifice offered for the living and the dead.

Strongly affirms

Marriage between two baptized Christians is a sacrament conveying grace.

Strongly affirms

The Supper is purely a memorial; the bread and wine remain only symbols that prompt remembrance, with no presence or reception of Christ.

Strongly rejects

The personal sin or unbelief of the minister invalidates the sacrament he administers.

Strongly rejects

No outward physical rites are necessary; the only true baptism and communion are inward and spiritual.

Strongly rejects

Baptism and the Supper are primarily acts of human obedience and public testimony rather than channels of divine grace.

Strongly rejects

Ordination imprints an indelible character on the ordained that cannot be lost.

Strongly affirms

Penance/reconciliation (confession, contrition, absolution, satisfaction) is a sacrament for the forgiveness of post-baptismal sin.

Strongly affirms

Christ's presence in the Supper exists only in the act of distribution and reception, not in elements set aside afterward.

Strongly rejects

An ordained priest has divinely given authority to forgive/retain sins in Christ's name.

Strongly affirms

Because all believers are priests, there is no distinct sacrificing/sacramental priesthood set apart from the laity.

Strongly rejects

Serious sins should be confessed privately to a priest, who pronounces absolution.

Strongly affirms

Christ is truly and really present in the bread and wine of the Supper, not merely symbolized.

Strongly affirms

Fermented wine, not grape juice, should be used in the Supper.

Strongly affirms

A person validly baptized in the name of the Trinity should never be rebaptized.

Strongly affirms

Consecrated elements should be reserved/retained for the sick and for ongoing devotion.

Strongly affirms

The exact number of sacraments is not strictly fixed by Scripture and may be counted differently.

Strongly rejects

A sacrament is rightly defined as a visible sign of an invisible grace: a "visible word."

Strongly affirms

A consummated sacramental marriage is absolutely indissoluble; no divorce can break the bond before death.

Strongly affirms

The sacraments/ordinances are not merely symbols but are means through which God actually conveys grace.

Strongly affirms

The penitent must perform acts of satisfaction (penance) assigned by the confessor as part of reconciliation.

Strongly affirms

There are seven sacraments: baptism, confirmation/chrismation, Eucharist, penance, anointing of the sick, holy orders, and matrimony.

Strongly affirms

In marriage the spouses themselves are the ministers of the sacrament; the priest is a witness.

Strongly affirms

Valid ordained ministry requires bishops, priests, and deacons in apostolic succession.

Strongly affirms

In consecration the bread and wine are changed in substance into the body and blood of Christ, the appearances alone remaining.

Strongly affirms

Valid baptism must use the Trinitarian formula "in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit."

Strongly affirms

The Eucharistic bread must be unleavened.

Strongly affirms

Only men may be validly ordained to the priesthood/presbyterate.

Strongly affirms

The church should anoint the sick with oil and pray over them for healing (per James 5).

Strongly affirms

The Holy Spirit is given/sealed to the recipient in water baptism itself.

Strongly affirms

Valid baptism requires full immersion of the body in water.

Strongly rejects

The mode of baptism (immersion, pouring, or sprinkling) is a matter of indifference and does not affect validity.

Strongly affirms

Baptism performed outside the one true Church is invalid and must be redone upon entry.

Strongly rejects

The Supper should be restricted to members of one's own church/confession in good standing.

Strongly affirms

Confession of sin directly to God is fully sufficient for forgiveness; no human mediator is needed.

Strongly rejects

An unworthy or unbelieving recipient still truly receives the sacramental substance, but to their own judgment.

Strongly affirms

All baptized believers (or all who love Christ) should be welcome at the Table regardless of denomination.

Strongly rejects

Baptized infants and young children should receive communion before a profession of faith or first confession.

Strongly rejects

Christ is truly received in the Supper by faith through the Holy Spirit, but his body is in heaven and not locally present in the elements.

Strongly rejects

Communion should be observed every week.

Strongly affirms

Baptism by sprinkling (aspersion) is a fully valid mode.

Affirms

Chrismation/confirmation should be administered immediately with baptism, even to infants.

Rejects

A sacrament benefits the recipient only when received with faith; without faith it conveys no grace (or conveys judgment).

Rejects

The bread and wine genuinely become Christ's body and blood, but the manner is a mystery not to be explained by substance/accident philosophy.

Rejects

Apostolic "household" baptisms warrant baptizing the whole family, including its children, on the faith of the head.

Affirms

A true sacrament must have been directly instituted by Christ himself.

Rejects

Sacraments function chiefly to confirm, seal, and strengthen a faith already given, rather than to originate grace.

Rejects

The Supper is a sacrifice only in the sense of the congregation's thanksgiving, praise, and self-offering.

Rejects

Baptism should be administered by three immersions, one for each person of the Trinity.

Rejects

The laity should receive both the bread and the cup (not bread alone).

Affirms

Baptism is the New Covenant sign of membership corresponding to circumcision, hence applied to covenant children.

Leans toward affirming

Confirmation is properly an occasion for a baptized person to profess for themselves the faith into which they were baptized.

Leans toward rejecting
Worship & liturgy71 positions · 48 held strongly

The worship space should be ordered around an altar/holy table as its visual and theological focus.

Strongly affirms

Clergy should wear distinctive liturgical vestments (alb, chasuble, stole, etc.) when leading worship.

Strongly affirms

Daily celebration of the Eucharist/Mass is a good and valuable practice.

Strongly affirms

The Eucharist/Lord's Supper is the central act and climax of corporate worship.

Strongly affirms

Feast days honoring the Virgin Mary and the saints are a proper part of the worship calendar.

Strongly affirms

The first day of the week (Sunday) is the proper day for Christian corporate worship.

Strongly affirms

Worship should follow a fixed, prescribed liturgical order and set texts (a missal, prayer book, or Divine Liturgy).

Strongly affirms

Worship should be free and led by the Spirit in the moment rather than bound to a fixed written order.

Strongly rejects

No images or visual representations should be present in the worship space; worship is by word and sacrament alone.

Strongly rejects

Kneeling is a fitting and proper posture for prayer and reception in corporate worship.

Strongly affirms

Scripture readings in worship should follow an appointed lectionary cycle rather than the preacher's free choice.

Strongly affirms

The church year (Advent, Christmas, Lent, Holy Week, Easter, Pentecost, and saints'/feast days) should structure the worship of the church.

Strongly affirms

Worship leaders should dress plainly like the congregation, without special clerical garb.

Strongly rejects

Reciting the historic creeds (Nicene, Apostles') corporately is a proper element of worship.

Strongly affirms

Observing humanly appointed holy days and seasons (including Christmas and Easter as feasts) is unwarranted by Scripture and ought to be rejected.

Strongly rejects

The reserved consecrated host (tabernacle/aumbry) is a proper focus of devotion in the worship space.

Strongly affirms

Worship should include responsive/dialogical elements where the congregation speaks set responses to the minister.

Strongly affirms

Making the sign of the cross is a fitting devotional gesture in worship.

Strongly affirms

Statues, crucifixes, and religious images are proper aids to devotion in the place of worship.

Strongly affirms

The Lord's Prayer should be recited corporately as a regular part of worship.

Strongly affirms

The Lord's Supper should be celebrated every Lord's Day.

Strongly affirms

A public invitation/altar call inviting people to come forward to receive Christ or rededicate is a fitting close to worship.

Strongly rejects

Bowing, prostration, or full physical reverence before the altar, icons, or sacrament is fitting in worship.

Strongly affirms

Liturgical candles and lamps are a proper part of the worship setting.

Strongly affirms

Chant (plainsong, Byzantine, Gregorian) is an especially fitting and proper musical form for worship.

Strongly affirms

A trained choir or cantor rightly leads or carries much of the sung worship on the congregation's behalf.

Strongly affirms

Communion seasons (a few solemn observances a year with extensive preparation) are the fitting pattern.

Strongly rejects

Only the inspired Psalms (or canonical biblical songs) may be sung in worship: no uninspired hymns.

Strongly rejects

Public prayer should be extemporaneous and from the heart rather than read from a book.

Strongly rejects

Appointed fasting seasons (Lent, Orthodox fasts, Ember days) are a proper discipline of corporate worship life.

Strongly affirms

The biblical feasts of the Hebrew calendar (Passover, Pentecost/Shavuot, Tabernacles) should be observed by Christians in worship.

Strongly rejects

The burning of incense is a fitting offering in corporate worship.

Strongly affirms

Communion is rightly observed occasionally (monthly, quarterly, or a few times a year) rather than weekly.

Strongly rejects

Musical instruments (organ, piano, guitars, drums, etc.) are a legitimate aid to congregational worship.

Strongly affirms

Men should worship with heads uncovered as a matter of reverence and biblical instruction.

Strongly affirms

Only feasts directly commemorating events in Christ's life (Christmas, Easter, Pentecost) are warranted; saints' days are not.

Strongly rejects

A formal exchange of the peace (greeting one another with a sign of peace) is a fitting liturgical act.

Strongly affirms

Liturgical processions (with cross, gospel book, icons, or sacrament) are a proper element of worship.

Strongly affirms

The worship space should be ordered around a central, elevated pulpit as its focus.

Strongly rejects

Corporate worship may include only those elements positively commanded or warranted by Scripture; whatever is not commanded is forbidden.

Strongly rejects

The second commandment forbids making any image of God or using images in worship.

Strongly rejects

Prepared, written prayers (collects, the prayer book) are a proper and preferred form of corporate prayer.

Strongly affirms

The seventh-day (Saturday) Sabbath remains binding and is the proper day of worship and rest.

Strongly rejects

Standing is the fitting posture for prayer and for hearing the Gospel/Scripture read.

Strongly affirms

Time for spontaneous personal testimonies by members is a fitting part of corporate worship.

Strongly rejects

The outward form and style of worship is largely a matter of indifference (adiaphora) to be decided by culture, pastoral wisdom, or preference.

Strongly rejects

The received liturgical tradition of the church carries binding authority over the form of worship alongside (or beyond) explicit Scripture.

Strongly affirms

Worship ought to be marked above all by reverence, solemnity, and awe before God's transcendence.

Strongly affirms

Modern stage production (amplified bands, lighting, screens, video) is a fitting medium for worship.

Rejects

Children should remain present in the main worship assembly throughout, rather than being separated into children's church.

Affirms

The laity should observe distinctive modest dress codes (plain clothing, no adornment) for worship.

Rejects

Singing in worship should be unaccompanied by musical instruments (a cappella only).

Rejects

A simple ministerial gown (Geneva gown / academic robe) rather than sacramental vestments is the fitting dress for the preacher.

Rejects

Icons of Christ and the saints should be venerated (honored with bows, kisses, candles, incense) in worship.

Affirms

Religious art may be used to teach and beautify, but must never receive veneration or devotion.

Rejects

The preaching/exposition of the Word is the central act and high point of corporate worship.

Rejects

A sermon is not an essential element of worship and may be brief or omitted.

Rejects

A substantial, lengthy sermon (30+ minutes) is a normal and expected feature of worship.

Rejects

Congregational singing is a divinely required element of corporate worship.

Affirms

Worship should be conducted in the everyday language of the people.

Affirms

Worship is fittingly conducted in homes or simple gatherings without a dedicated sacred building.

Rejects

A primary purpose of the worship service is evangelism and calling outsiders to conversion.

Rejects

Worship should be deliberately shaped to feel familiar and accessible to outsiders and the unchurched.

Rejects

Manifestations like being "slain in the Spirit," holy laughter, or falling under God's power are genuine works of the Spirit in worship.

Rejects

Contemporary worship music (CCM, praise-and-worship bands, modern choruses) is fitting and desirable for the gathered church.

Rejects

A fixed sacred or traditional liturgical language (Latin, Church Slavonic, Koine Greek, classical Syriac, Ge'ez) is fitting and preferable for worship.

Affirms

The sermon should be primarily an exposition of a biblical text rather than topical, exhortatory, or homiletic reflection.

Rejects

The Lord's Day requires strict cessation from labor, commerce, and recreation, set apart wholly for worship and rest.

Rejects

The collection of tithes and offerings is itself an act of worship within the service.

Affirms

Speaking in tongues during the gathered worship service is a legitimate and welcome practice.

Rejects

Women should wear head coverings (veils, hats, prayer caps) during corporate worship.

Rejects
Last things64 positions · 38 held strongly

The "antichrist" / "beast" is best identified with an ongoing institution (historically, the papal office) rather than a single future man.

Strongly rejects

The supreme reward of the redeemed is the direct, face-to-face vision of God himself (the beatific vision).

Strongly affirms

Jesus Christ will return personally, visibly, and bodily to the earth at a future point in history.

Strongly affirms

At death the believer's soul consciously enters the presence of Christ and remains aware while awaiting the bodily resurrection.

Strongly affirms

It is possible, by study of prophecy, to calculate or closely estimate the time of the end.

Strongly rejects

Satan and the fallen angels are consigned to eternal punishment in the lake of fire.

Strongly affirms

There will be a final judgment at which all people are judged by Christ and assigned their eternal destinies.

Strongly affirms

There will be a future, literal resurrection of the body: the dead raised with transformed physical bodies.

Strongly affirms

The finally unrepentant suffer conscious punishment in hell that continues without end.

Strongly affirms

Immortality is not innate but is given by God only to the saved; the lost do not possess unending existence.

Strongly rejects

Between death and the resurrection the person exists as a disembodied soul, separated from the body that awaits raising.

Strongly affirms

The finally lost are ultimately destroyed and cease to exist rather than suffering unending conscious torment (annihilationism/conditional immortality).

Strongly rejects

There is no distinct "rapture" doctrine at all; the New Testament describes one return of Christ at which the living and the dead are gathered together.

Strongly affirms

Each soul faces a "particular judgment" determining its provisional destiny immediately at death, distinct from the general judgment at the end.

Strongly affirms

Prayers, almsgiving, or the Eucharist offered for the departed can benefit them in the intermediate state.

Strongly affirms

Many of the saved undergo a purifying process after death (purgatory) before entering the fullness of heaven.

Strongly affirms

Believers will be removed from the earth before a future seven-year tribulation period begins (pretribulationism).

Strongly rejects

There is a "rapture" (a catching-up of living believers to meet Christ) that is a distinct event, separated in time from his visible return to earth.

Strongly rejects

The decisive "coming of the Son of Man" prophesied in the Gospels was fulfilled in the events surrounding the destruction of Jerusalem in AD 70, not a still-future event.

Strongly rejects

Language about Christ's "return" is best understood symbolically (as the ongoing triumph of his cause or spiritual presence) rather than as a single future historical event.

Strongly rejects

The righteous and the wicked are raised together in one general resurrection at the end of the age.

Strongly affirms

The human soul is inherently immortal by nature and cannot cease to exist.

Strongly affirms

The dead are unconscious ("asleep") and have no awareness or experience until they are raised at the resurrection.

Strongly rejects

In the end all rational creatures will be reconciled to God and none will be finally lost (universal reconciliation/apokatastasis).

Strongly rejects

Christ returns bodily before the millennial kingdom and personally inaugurates it on earth.

Strongly rejects

In the final state there are real differences of degree: greater and lesser rewards for the saved, greater and lesser punishment for the lost.

Strongly affirms

Final hope is essentially the immortality of the soul in a spiritual realm, not the raising and transformation of the physical body.

Strongly rejects

Israel and the church are two distinct peoples with distinct programs and promises that are never merged.

Strongly rejects

Believers will be judged for their works to determine differing degrees of reward (while their salvation itself is secure).

Strongly affirms

A future millennial temple with a restored sacrificial system (memorial in nature) will function during Christ's earthly reign.

Strongly rejects

The thousand-year reign of Christ (Revelation 20) denotes a literal, future, earthly period of roughly a thousand years.

Strongly rejects

The "thousand years" is a symbol for the entire present age between Christ's first and second comings, during which he reigns from heaven.

Strongly affirms

The present creation will be renewed, redeemed, and transformed (not annihilated and replaced) into the new heavens and new earth.

Strongly affirms

The gathering of believers occurs at the very end, simultaneous with Christ's visible return, after the church has gone through tribulation (posttribulationism).

Strongly affirms

The resurrection body is a real, physical body in genuine continuity with the body that died, though glorified and incorruptible.

Strongly affirms

There are two distinct resurrections: the righteous raised before the millennium and the rest raised after it.

Strongly rejects

We are currently living in the biblically described "last days."

Strongly affirms

The age will end in increasing apostasy, deception, and tribulation rather than in a Christianized golden age.

Strongly affirms

A literal future "mark of the beast" will be imposed as a condition of economic participation.

Affirms

The gospel will gradually Christianize the world, producing a long age of righteousness and peace, after which Christ returns.

Rejects

The church will be present on earth during the final tribulation and will be preserved through it rather than removed from it.

Affirms

The end is deification (theosis), participation in God's uncreated energies, rather than a vision of the divine essence.

Rejects

A specific future seven-year period of unprecedented tribulation (often tied to Daniel's seventieth week) remains to be fulfilled.

Rejects

Hell is best understood as the self-chosen, freely persisted-in separation from God rather than externally imposed physical torture.

Affirms

The Old Testament land promises to Israel await a literal, future, territorial fulfillment.

Rejects

The founding and existence of the modern political State of Israel is a fulfillment of biblical prophecy.

Rejects

The present heavens and earth will be wholly destroyed and replaced by an entirely new creation.

Rejects

The catching-up of believers may be a sudden, partly secret event in which people vanish before the watching world.

Rejects

Christ's return could occur at any moment, with no remaining prophecy that must be fulfilled first.

Rejects

Revelation symbolically charts the course of church history from the apostles to the end, age by age.

Rejects

Resurrected and/or transformed believers will reign with Christ on a renewed earth during the millennial period.

Rejects

After death the soul passes through a series of trials or "toll-houses" where it is tested by demonic accusers.

Rejects

A specific future individual (the antichrist / man of lawlessness / beast) will arise as a world ruler before the end.

Affirms

The prophecies of Daniel and Revelation should be read primarily as literal predictions of still-future events.

Rejects

The church is the new and true Israel; national Israel has no remaining distinct prophetic role (supersessionism/replacement).

Affirms

The blessed make endless progress ever deeper into God, with no final, static point of arrival.

Rejects

Ethnic/national Israel has a distinct future in God's plan: a large-scale future conversion and/or restoration as a people.

Rejects

The eternal destiny of the redeemed is embodied life on a renewed earth, not a disembodied existence in a non-material heaven.

Affirms

The ultimate home of the saved is a heavenly, spiritual realm rather than a physical renewed earth.

Affirms

Christ's return will be accompanied by literal cosmic upheaval: darkened sun, falling stars, and visible glory seen by all.

Affirms

The "fire" of the lake of fire denotes literal fire rather than a metaphor for divine judgment or anguish.

Leans toward rejecting

While not asserting it as doctrine, one may legitimately hope and pray that all may ultimately be saved.

Leans toward affirming

Unbaptized infants who die occupy a state of natural happiness apart from the beatific vision (the "limbo of infants").

Leans toward affirming

Identifiable signs (wars, earthquakes, gospel preached to all nations, rise of deception) will mark the approach of the end and can be discerned.

Leans toward affirming
Scripture73 positions · 48 held strongly

The authentic interpretation of Scripture is entrusted to the Church's living teaching office (Magisterium), whose judgments bind the faithful.

Strongly affirms

The Church should bind conscience to "no creed but the Bible," rejecting man-made confessions as tests of fellowship.

Strongly rejects

Scripture and apostolic Tradition together form one deposit of God's Word, both to be received with equal devotion.

Strongly affirms

Scripture is the sole infallible rule of faith and practice for the Church.

Strongly rejects

The Church, exercising her God-given authority, determined and authoritatively defined which books are canonical.

Strongly affirms

The canon of Scripture is permanently closed; no new books can be added.

Strongly affirms

The deuterocanonical/apocryphal books (e.g., Tobit, Wisdom, Sirach, 1-2 Maccabees) are fully canonical Scripture.

Strongly affirms

Books such as 1 Enoch and Jubilees belong in the biblical canon.

Strongly rejects

The Old Testament should be rejected or radically subordinated because its God differs from the God revealed in Jesus.

Strongly rejects

Scripture includes additional latter-day revealed books beyond the Bible (e.g., the Book of Mormon, Doctrine and Covenants, Pearl of Great Price).

Strongly rejects

The Old Testament is fully and equally Scripture alongside the New Testament.

Strongly affirms

The canon of Scripture is open in principle: God may add new authoritative written revelation in the present or future.

Strongly rejects

The canon of Scripture consists of exactly the 66 books of the Protestant Bible.

Strongly rejects

God's revelation in nature and conscience gives reliable, though limited, knowledge of God independent of Scripture.

Strongly affirms

Beyond the literal sense, Scripture carries genuine spiritual senses (allegorical, moral, anagogical) intended by God.

Strongly affirms

Obscure passages of Scripture should be interpreted in light of clearer passages ("the analogy of Scripture").

Strongly affirms

Scripture must be interpreted according to the Church's "rule of faith" / received tradition, which constrains permissible readings.

Strongly affirms

Old Testament persons and events are divinely intended types that prefigure New Testament realities.

Strongly affirms

God so worked through the human authors that their own personalities, vocabulary, and circumstances genuinely shaped the text while it remained God's word.

Strongly affirms

The Holy Spirit is properly called the divine author of Scripture.

Strongly affirms

All parts of Scripture are equally inspired, not merely the doctrinally central or "religious" portions.

Strongly affirms

The Christian Scriptures originated through a genuine act of God, not merely human religious reflection.

Strongly affirms

Through the Holy Spirit, Scripture speaks directly and personally to the believer today, not merely as an ancient record.

Strongly affirms

The Christian Scriptures are uniquely God's word in a way that the sacred texts of other religions are not.

Strongly affirms

The King James Version is the only fully reliable English Bible, and modern translations are corrupt or doctrinally dangerous.

Strongly rejects

Present-day prophecy or apostolic revelation can supplement Scripture as a source of binding guidance.

Strongly rejects

An individual believer may rightly stand on Scripture against the consensus of the Church when conscience so requires.

Strongly rejects

The apocryphal books are profitable for reading and edification but are not authoritative for establishing doctrine.

Strongly rejects

The Church recognized the canon that God had already constituted, rather than creating or conferring canonicity.

Strongly rejects

The canonical books are self-authenticating: believers recognize them as Scripture through the internal witness of the Holy Spirit, not by the Church's decree.

Strongly rejects

Any verse may be applied directly as binding doctrine or command regardless of its covenant or redemptive-historical context.

Strongly rejects

Prophetic texts should be read as literally and concretely as possible, including a future literal fulfillment of national/territorial promises to Israel.

Strongly rejects

All of Scripture finds its unifying meaning in Christ and the unfolding plan of redemption, and should be read Christocentrically.

Strongly affirms

The historical narratives of Scripture (e.g., the exodus, the conquest, the bodily resurrection) record events that actually happened in space and time.

Strongly affirms

Scripture is infallible in matters of faith and salvation but may contain incidental errors in history, science, or geography.

Strongly affirms

Scripture's descriptions of nature (e.g., the sun rising) are ordinary phenomenological language and do not constitute scientific error.

Strongly affirms

The Bible is not in itself the Word of God but becomes the Word of God in the event of God addressing a person through it.

Strongly rejects

God dictated the words of Scripture to the human writers, who functioned essentially as scribes or stenographers.

Strongly rejects

"Inspiration" refers only to the heightened spiritual insight of gifted human authors, comparable in kind (if not degree) to other great religious writing.

Strongly rejects

The same inspiration that produced Scripture continues to operate in the Church, potentially producing new authoritative texts today.

Strongly rejects

Scripture is necessary for a saving and reliable knowledge of God that nature alone cannot provide.

Strongly affirms

Scripture is sufficiently obscure that private readers will go astray without the Church's authoritative guidance.

Strongly affirms

Some of Scripture's moral teachings are culturally conditioned and may be revised or set aside in light of contemporary moral insight.

Strongly rejects

Every believer should read the Scriptures directly in their own language.

Strongly affirms

Scripture's authority is exercised chiefly through its public proclamation and the sacraments, rather than primarily through private reading.

Strongly affirms

The best New Testament text is reconstructed by weighing all manuscript evidence (an eclectic/critical text), even where this differs from the historic printed editions.

Strongly affirms

A translation can itself be inspired or providentially perfected, not merely an approximation of the inspired original.

Strongly rejects

What Scripture "affirms" must be judged by each passage's literary genre, so poetry, parable, and apocalyptic are not measured by historical-factual standards.

Strongly affirms

The ecumenical creeds and confessions are authoritative only insofar as they faithfully summarize Scripture.

Rejects

Scripture is rightly read only within Holy Tradition: the Fathers, councils, liturgy, and consensus of the Church.

Affirms

Scripture is the primary authority, but tradition and reason serve as genuine, subordinate authorities under it.

Rejects

Books beyond the Roman Catholic canon (e.g., 3 Maccabees, Psalm 151, 1 Esdras, and in some churches 4 Maccabees or Enoch) are rightly received as Scripture.

Rejects

Critical-historical study (source, form, and redaction criticism) is a legitimate and necessary tool for understanding Scripture.

Affirms

The literal sense (the plain, intended meaning) is the foundation and control for all other senses of Scripture.

Affirms

The meaning of a biblical text is significantly constituted by the reader or community, not fixed solely by authorial intent.

Rejects

God accommodated the limited knowledge of the human authors, so the Bible can reflect the erroneous cosmology or science of its time without compromising its religious message.

Affirms

The Bible contains real errors and contradictions, and Christian faith does not depend on its factual accuracy.

Rejects

Some books or passages of Scripture are more fully inspired than others.

Rejects

Inspiration extends to the actual words of the original text, not only to the general ideas or concepts.

Affirms

The recorded words of Jesus carry greater authority than other portions of Scripture.

Rejects

Scripture is best understood as a fallible human witness pointing to revelation, rather than as revelation itself.

Rejects

Individual believers, illumined by the Spirit, are competent to interpret Scripture for themselves.

Rejects

The essential teachings of Scripture, especially the way of salvation, are clear enough that ordinary believers can understand them without a specialized interpreter.

Rejects

The Word of God is a means of grace that effectively works faith and salvation, not merely conveys information.

Affirms

Only what Scripture positively commands or warrants may be included in the Church's worship and government.

Rejects

Scripture contains all things necessary for salvation and for the faith and life of the Church; nothing essential is lacking.

Rejects

Bible translation should follow the original wording and structure as closely as possible (formal/word-for-word equivalence).

Affirms

Scripture in its original manuscripts is entirely without error in all that it affirms, including matters of history and the natural world, not only faith and morals.

Affirms

Bible translation should prioritize conveying the meaning in clear contemporary language even at the cost of literal wording (dynamic/functional equivalence).

Affirms

Every doctrine the Church teaches must be testable by, and answerable to, Scripture.

Leans toward affirming

Allegorical and figurative interpretation, rather than the literal-historical, should be the default key to Scripture's deeper meaning.

Leans toward rejecting

The proper method of interpretation seeks the single intended meaning of the human author in his historical and grammatical context.

Leans toward affirming

The early chapters of Genesis (creation, the fall, the flood) are intended as real history rather than primarily theological symbol or ancient myth.

Leans toward rejecting
Revelation, creation & science51 positions · 37 held strongly

The first human was specially and directly created by God from the dust, not biologically descended from earlier hominins.

Strongly affirms

Angels and other spiritual beings are part of God's created order, made by God.

Strongly affirms

There is no genuine knowledge of God available through nature or human reason apart from God's revelation in Jesus Christ.

Strongly rejects

The miracles recorded in Scripture (e.g., the parting of the sea, Jesus' healings, walking on water) actually occurred as described.

Strongly affirms

God created the universe out of nothing (ex nihilo), not from pre-existing matter.

Strongly affirms

God continually sustains the universe in being; creation is not merely a past event but an ongoing dependence on God.

Strongly affirms

Creation has a real divine purpose and direction (telos), not merely the appearance of order arising from undirected processes.

Strongly affirms

God created the world and established its laws but does not intervene with miracles or verbal revelation; he is known through reason and nature alone.

Strongly rejects

Caring for the created order (environmental stewardship) is a genuine theological duty flowing from the doctrine of creation.

Strongly affirms

Biological evolution is an entirely unguided, purposeless process requiring no divine involvement of any kind.

Strongly rejects

The human conscience and moral sense are a form of God's revelation, giving real knowledge of right and wrong written on the heart.

Strongly affirms

God genuinely reveals something of himself through the natural world and the created order, apart from Scripture.

Strongly affirms

The one triune God is the sole creator of everything that exists, including all spiritual and material reality.

Strongly affirms

The fall of humanity into sin was a real historical event by the first humans, not merely a symbol of the universal human condition.

Strongly affirms

Humans bear the image of God in a way that sets them qualitatively apart from all other animals, by a special divine act or endowment.

Strongly affirms

The material, physical world is intrinsically good as God made it, not evil, illusory, or a prison for the soul.

Strongly affirms

God can and does act in the world in ways that supersede or suspend ordinary natural causes (genuine miracles are possible).

Strongly affirms

Whatever knowledge of God nature provides is insufficient for salvation; saving knowledge requires special revelation in Christ and Scripture.

Strongly affirms

Rational arguments (e.g., cosmological, teleological, moral) can validly demonstrate, or strongly support, the existence of God from observable reality.

Strongly affirms

The resurrection of Jesus was a real, bodily, historical event, not merely a symbol of hope or the disciples' inner experience.

Strongly affirms

Even if the human body has an evolutionary history, God specially creates or infuses a spiritual soul in each human (or in the first humans).

Strongly affirms

A clear and reliable knowledge of God and his saving purposes requires God's special, verbal self-revelation, not merely general revelation.

Strongly affirms

The universe (or some physical reality) is eternal and had no absolute beginning.

Strongly rejects

The Big Bang cosmology (a universe with a finite beginning ~13.8 billion years ago) is compatible with, or even supportive of, the doctrine of creation.

Strongly affirms

The miraculous and revelatory gifts (prophecy, tongues, healing) ceased with the apostolic age and are not normative today.

Strongly rejects

The present physical creation will be redeemed and renewed (a "new heavens and new earth"), not annihilated and replaced.

Strongly affirms

The "days" of Genesis 1 represent long ages or epochs, allowing for an old earth while keeping the sequence broadly historical.

Strongly rejects

Christian faith can and should be defended by appeal to publicly assessable evidence (historical, scientific, philosophical) weighed like any other claim.

Strongly affirms

Genesis 1-3 is intended as an account of actual historical events, not primarily as theological symbol, poetry, or myth.

Strongly affirms

Adam and Eve were real, historical individuals, the literal first human beings.

Strongly affirms

All human beings descend from a single original couple (monogenism).

Strongly affirms

God still performs miracles today (healings, signs, answered prayer beyond natural explanation) as he did in biblical times.

Strongly affirms

Human physical death is a consequence of sin; humans were created to be immortal in body and would not have died apart from the fall.

Strongly affirms

One cannot reason to God from religiously neutral premises; all knowledge must start by presupposing the triune God revealed in Scripture.

Strongly rejects

God ordinarily acts through natural laws and secondary causes, which are themselves his ongoing governance, rather than by frequent direct intervention.

Strongly affirms

Well-established scientific findings can legitimately guide and correct how we interpret the relevant parts of Scripture.

Strongly affirms

Modern science and Christian faith are fundamentally in conflict, so where they disagree, one must ultimately override the other.

Strongly rejects

God is best understood as creating continuously and in cooperation with an evolving, partly self-creating world (creatio continua), rather than as having finished creation.

Rejects

Young-earth "creation science" (and/or intelligent design) constitutes legitimate science that should be taught alongside or instead of mainstream accounts.

Rejects

The earth and universe are only thousands of years old (on the order of ~6,000-10,000 years).

Rejects

The fine-tuning of the universe's physical constants is real evidence of intelligent design or a divine designer.

Affirms

Genesis communicates theological truth using the cosmological assumptions of its ancient Near Eastern setting (a solid firmament, waters above), which need not be taken as literal science.

Affirms

The human population never passed through a single original couple but emerged as a group of several thousand individuals.

Rejects

Certain features of biology exhibit "irreducible" or "specified" complexity that is best explained by intelligent design and could not arise by unguided evolution.

Affirms

Properly interpreted Scripture and properly conducted science will agree, and apparent conflicts arise from misreading one or the other.

Affirms

The settled consensus of the natural sciences (e.g., on the age of the universe, common descent, the fossil record) is generally trustworthy.

Affirms

When the plain teaching of Scripture conflicts with a scientific consensus, Scripture must be followed and the science rejected or reinterpreted.

Rejects

God created living things, including humans, by means of the evolutionary process, including common descent.

Affirms

God created the universe and all kinds of life in six literal 24-hour days.

Rejects

The Genesis flood was a real, worldwide deluge that covered the entire globe and destroyed all land life outside the ark.

Rejects

There was no animal death, predation, or suffering before the fall of humanity; death entered the whole creation through Adam's sin.

Rejects
Life & bioethics80 positions · 71 held strongly

Methods that can prevent implantation of an already-fertilized embryo (e.g., certain IUDs, emergency contraception) are morally equivalent to early abortion and impermissible.

Strongly affirms

Access to abortion is a fundamental right that should be legally protected.

Strongly rejects

Abortion can be a morally responsible, even compassionate, choice that should not carry moral stigma.

Strongly rejects

Early abortion is significantly less morally serious than late-term abortion.

Strongly rejects

Deliberately ending a pregnancy by killing the unborn is in itself a grave moral wrong.

Strongly affirms

Abortion is morally permissible when the fetus has a severe anomaly or a condition incompatible with life.

Strongly rejects

Abortion is morally permissible when the pregnancy results from rape or incest.

Strongly rejects

Abortion is morally permissible for serious socioeconomic reasons (poverty, inability to care for a child, life disruption).

Strongly rejects

The decision to continue or end a pregnancy belongs to the pregnant woman alone.

Strongly rejects

Adult and induced-pluripotent stem cells (which do not require destroying embryos) are the morally preferable avenue for stem-cell medicine.

Strongly affirms

Full moral status and the protections of personhood begin only at birth.

Strongly rejects

A competent adult's autonomy over their own body is the decisive moral consideration in life-and-death medical choices.

Strongly rejects

Reproductive cloning of a human being is morally wrong.

Strongly affirms

Creating more embryos than will be transferred to the womb is morally wrong.

Strongly affirms

Engineering "designer babies" by selecting or editing for desired non-medical traits is morally wrong.

Strongly affirms

Destroying or discarding unused embryos is the killing of human beings.

Strongly affirms

Using donor sperm or eggs (third-party gametes) in reproduction is morally illicit.

Strongly affirms

An action with both a good and a foreseen-but-unintended bad effect can be permissible if the bad effect is not the means to the good and the goods are proportionate (the principle of double effect).

Strongly affirms

The early embryo is a potential person, not yet an actual person, and is owed respect proportioned to that potential.

Strongly rejects

Research that destroys human embryos to obtain stem cells is morally wrong.

Strongly affirms

Deliberately ending a patient's life to relieve suffering (active euthanasia) is always morally wrong.

Strongly affirms

Assisted dying may be appropriate for unbearable suffering even when the condition is not terminal (chronic illness, psychiatric suffering, disability).

Strongly rejects

One is not morally required to use extraordinary/disproportionate means (burdensome, futile, or excessively costly treatment) to prolong life.

Strongly affirms

Cryopreserving human embryos is morally problematic because it suspends and endangers human lives.

Strongly affirms

The moral status of the unborn increases gradually through gestation rather than being full from conception or absent until birth.

Strongly rejects

Medical professionals have a moral right to conscientiously refuse to perform or refer for abortions.

Strongly affirms

Human life possesses a special, inviolable dignity because human beings are made in the image of God.

Strongly affirms

The direct, intentional killing of an innocent human being is always gravely wrong, with no exceptions.

Strongly affirms

IVF using a married couple's own gametes is morally acceptable as a remedy for infertility.

Strongly rejects

In vitro fertilization is intrinsically morally illicit because it separates procreation from the marital act.

Strongly affirms

Assisted dying / euthanasia should be legally available with appropriate safeguards.

Strongly rejects

A protectable human life begins at implantation rather than at fertilization.

Strongly rejects

Human life is a gift over which we are stewards, not owners; we may not dispose of it (our own or another's) at will.

Strongly affirms

When the mother's life is at risk, only procedures that do not directly target the unborn (e.g., removing a diseased organ with foreseen fetal death) are licit: not a direct abortion.

Strongly affirms

Reason reflecting on human nature (natural law) yields binding moral norms for medicine, independent of explicit Scripture.

Strongly affirms

Non-abortifacient contraception (barrier/hormonal methods that prevent fertilization) is morally acceptable for married couples.

Strongly rejects

There is a moral obligation to use ordinary/proportionate means to preserve life (basic care, ordinarily-beneficial treatment).

Strongly affirms

A distinct human person, bearing full moral status, exists from the moment of conception/fertilization.

Strongly affirms

Full moral status (personhood) depends on actualized capacities such as consciousness, sentience, or rationality, which the early embryo lacks.

Strongly rejects

Pre-implantation genetic diagnosis used to select which embryos to implant (and discard the rest) is morally wrong.

Strongly affirms

A physician may permissibly help a competent, terminally ill patient end their own life at the patient's request.

Strongly rejects

In some cases (e.g., severe anomaly), ending the life of a newborn could be ethically comparable to late abortion.

Strongly rejects

When a life involves sufficient suffering or loss of function, considerations of "quality of life" can outweigh the duty to preserve it.

Strongly rejects

Reducing a multiple pregnancy by aborting one or more fetuses ("selective reduction") is morally wrong.

Strongly affirms

Buying or selling human organs is morally wrong (commodification of the body).

Strongly affirms

Surrogate pregnancy (gestating a child for another couple) is morally illicit.

Strongly affirms

Creating cloned human embryos for research or therapy (therapeutic cloning), then destroying them, is morally wrong.

Strongly affirms

There is a morally significant difference between actively killing a patient and allowing them to die by withholding/withdrawing treatment.

Strongly affirms

Abortion is morally permissible when continuing the pregnancy would directly threaten the mother's life.

Strongly rejects

Abortion is impermissible in all circumstances, including rape, incest, fetal anomaly, and threat to the mother's life.

Strongly affirms

Justice positively requires the execution of murderers (life-for-life retribution as a moral duty, not merely a permission).

Strongly rejects

The death penalty should be abolished in practice today.

Strongly affirms

Creating human-animal hybrids or chimeras for research is morally wrong.

Strongly affirms

A coherent ethic of life must oppose abortion, euthanasia, capital punishment, and unjust war alike ("seamless garment" / consistent life ethic).

Strongly affirms

Sedating a dying patient into unconsciousness to relieve otherwise intractable suffering (palliative/terminal sedation) is morally acceptable when death is not the intended aim.

Strongly affirms

Vital organs may be taken only after the donor is truly dead (the "dead donor rule" must not be relaxed).

Strongly affirms

Do-not-resuscitate orders are morally acceptable when resuscitation would be futile or excessively burdensome.

Strongly affirms

Using genetic technology to enhance traits beyond the treatment of disease (intelligence, appearance, ability) is morally wrong.

Strongly affirms

Editing the human germline (heritable changes passed to descendants) is morally wrong.

Strongly affirms

The rational soul is infused by God at the moment of conception.

Strongly affirms

Taking human life can be morally justified in some circumstances (just war, defense of the innocent, lawful execution).

Strongly affirms

Donating a non-vital organ (e.g., a kidney) while alive, out of charity, is morally acceptable.

Strongly affirms

Artificially administered nutrition and hydration are basic care that may (almost) never be withdrawn, even from permanently unconscious patients.

Strongly affirms

Donating one's organs after death is a morally good and praiseworthy act of charity.

Strongly affirms

Giving pain relief sufficient to control suffering is acceptable even if it foreseeably (but unintentionally) shortens life.

Strongly affirms

Conceiving and selecting a child specifically to be a tissue/organ donor for an existing sibling ("saviour sibling") treats the child as a means and is wrong.

Strongly affirms

Using lethal force to defend oneself or others from a deadly attacker is morally permissible.

Strongly affirms

Genetic modification of a patient's body cells to treat disease (somatic gene therapy) is morally acceptable.

Strongly affirms

Suicide (taking one's own life) is morally wrong.

Strongly affirms

Human life must be preserved by every available medical means for as long as possible, regardless of burden or prognosis.

Strongly rejects

Withdrawing or withholding life-sustaining treatment can be morally licit when it is futile or excessively burdensome.

Strongly affirms

A competent person's advance directive refusing future treatment should be respected.

Affirms

Irreversible loss of all brain function (brain death) constitutes the genuine death of the person.

Affirms

The rational soul is infused only after the body has reached a sufficient stage of formation (delayed hominization), not at fertilization.

Rejects

Scripture grants the civil authority a God-given right to wield lethal force ("the sword") against grave wrongdoing.

Affirms

Paying a woman to gestate a child (commercial surrogacy) is specifically wrong as commodification, even if altruistic surrogacy might be tolerated.

Affirms

Late-term abortion (third trimester) is gravely wrong even where earlier abortion might be tolerated.

Affirms

The state may, in principle, justly impose the death penalty for the gravest crimes.

Leans toward rejecting

Adopting and gestating abandoned frozen embryos ("embryo adoption" / snowflake adoption) is a praiseworthy way to rescue them.

Leans toward rejecting

Substantially redesigning human biology through technology usurps a prerogative belonging to God ("playing God").

Leans toward affirming
Sexuality & marriage76 positions · 57 held strongly

Contraceptive methods that may act after fertilization (potential abortifacients) are morally wrong even if other contraception is permitted.

Strongly affirms

Some unions that appeared to be marriages were never valid marriages, and the church can rightly declare them null (annulment).

Strongly affirms

Artificial contraception (barrier, hormonal, sterilization) is intrinsically morally wrong.

Strongly affirms

The human body has an intrinsic, God-given sexual meaning (e.g. male-female complementarity) that moral choices must honor rather than redefine.

Strongly affirms

Consecrated celibacy/virginity is a higher or more excellent state than marriage.

Strongly affirms

Where Scripture and the body's design conflict with a person's desires, the faithful response is costly obedience (including lifelong celibacy), not revising the teaching.

Strongly affirms

Chastity (rightly ordered sexuality according to one's state in life) is a positive virtue to be actively cultivated, not merely abstinence.

Strongly affirms

Those ordained to the priesthood/ministry should be celibate.

Strongly affirms

It is morally acceptable for an unmarried couple to live together (cohabit) in a sexual relationship.

Strongly rejects

Married couples may use contraception freely as a matter of prudent stewardship, with no moral cloud over it.

Strongly rejects

Every marital sexual act must remain open to the possibility of procreation.

Strongly affirms

Christians who experience exclusive same-sex attraction are called to lifelong celibacy or to a mixed-orientation marriage with the opposite sex.

Strongly affirms

A person's internal gender identity can legitimately differ from their birth sex and should be respected as their true gender.

Strongly rejects

The sex/gender of one's partner is morally irrelevant; the same covenantal standards apply to same-sex and opposite-sex relationships alike.

Strongly rejects

Even within marriage, some sexual acts are morally illicit (not "anything goes" between spouses).

Strongly affirms

Marriage is a living icon/sign of the union between Christ and the church, and this shapes its norms (including its male-female form).

Strongly affirms

Marriage is essentially a covenant (a binding, God-witnessed promise) more than a contract or a means to ends.

Strongly affirms

Marriage between the baptized is a sacrament that confers grace.

Strongly affirms

A valid, consummated marriage is absolutely indissoluble; nothing but death ends it.

Strongly affirms

Marriage is by nature a lifelong, exclusively monogamous union.

Strongly affirms

By definition and divine design, marriage is the union of one man and one woman.

Strongly affirms

A valid marriage requires proper canonical form, free consent, and openness to its essential ends; defects in these can void it.

Strongly affirms

Masturbation is morally wrong.

Strongly affirms

Medical gender transition (hormones, surgery) can be a morally appropriate response to gender dysphoria.

Strongly rejects

Spacing or limiting births by natural family planning (periodic abstinence) is morally acceptable for serious reasons, where artificial means are not.

Strongly affirms

A natural-law reading of the body and its built-in purposes (apart from any single proof-text) establishes objective norms for sexual acts.

Strongly affirms

Non-binary or genderfluid identities are valid and should be affirmed.

Strongly rejects

The church may, by pastoral mercy ("economia"), permit a second or third marriage with a penitential rite even though it is less than the ideal.

Strongly rejects

Consensual polyamorous or "ethical non-monogamous" relationships can be morally legitimate.

Strongly rejects

Polygamy (one man, multiple wives) is morally wrong for Christians.

Strongly affirms

Using pornography is morally wrong.

Strongly affirms

Premarital sex (fornication) is always sinful, even between an engaged or committed couple.

Strongly affirms

Procreation (the bearing and raising of children) is a primary, defining end of marriage.

Strongly affirms

Remarriage while a former spouse is living constitutes adultery.

Strongly affirms

Any divorced person may remarry, regardless of fault in the prior divorce.

Strongly rejects

The innocent party in a biblically justified divorce is free to remarry.

Strongly rejects

Sexual acts between two people of the same sex are always morally wrong.

Strongly affirms

Same-sex sexual attraction is an objective disorder of desire even when not acted upon.

Strongly affirms

A covenanted union between two people of the same sex can be a true marriage in God's sight.

Strongly rejects

Scripture provides binding, authoritative norms for sexual conduct that the church is not free to revise.

Strongly affirms

A person's sex is a fixed, binary, God-given reality determined at conception, not something that can be changed.

Strongly affirms

Sexual intercourse is morally reserved exclusively for marriage.

Strongly affirms

Sexual acts between consenting adults are morally permissible unless they cause harm; consent and care, not act-type, are the decisive criteria.

Strongly rejects

Lifelong singleness is a full and equal Christian vocation, not a lesser or transitional state.

Strongly affirms

The consistent, unbroken teaching of the historic church on sex and marriage is itself a decisive authority that cannot be overturned.

Strongly affirms

A vow of lifelong celibacy (religious life) is genuinely binding before God and should not be dispensed lightly.

Strongly affirms

Women may be ordained as pastors/priests and hold the church's highest teaching/governing office.

Strongly rejects

A married couple may in good conscience choose to remain permanently childless.

Strongly rejects

Distinct roles for men and women are rooted in the created order, not merely in culture or the curse.

Strongly affirms

Divorce is also permitted when an unbelieving or abusive spouse deserts/abandons the marriage (the "Pauline privilege" / desertion ground).

Strongly rejects

Divorce is permitted in the case of a spouse's sexual unfaithfulness (the "exception clause").

Strongly rejects

The lived experience and conscience of faithful believers (including LGBTQ Christians) is a legitimate source that can correct inherited sexual teaching.

Strongly rejects

Gender dysphoria should be met with compassion and care aimed at reconciling the person to their birth sex, not at transition.

Strongly affirms

Internal lustful desire/fantasy, even without any outward act, is itself sin.

Strongly affirms

One's stance and conduct on sexual ethics bears on salvation/standing before God, not merely on discipleship maturity.

Strongly affirms

A person's prior sexual history has no bearing on their purity, worth, or "marriageability" before God.

Strongly affirms

The church should hold up virginity-until-marriage as a clear normative expectation and teach it as such to youth.

Strongly affirms

The church should liturgically bless and solemnize same-sex unions.

Rejects

A marriage contracted before the state (civil marriage) is a fully valid marriage in God's sight.

Rejects

A person divorced and civilly remarried without annulment should be barred from receiving Communion.

Affirms

The husband is the divinely appointed head of the wife, who is called to submit to his leadership.

Affirms

A man already in a polygamous marriage when he converts may remain married to all his wives rather than being required to divorce.

Rejects

People in same-sex relationships should be welcomed into full church membership without requiring they end the relationship.

Rejects

A same-sex orientation or attraction, in itself (apart from acting on it), is not sinful.

Affirms

Sexual pleasure within marriage is a genuine good to be enjoyed for its own sake, not merely tolerated for procreation.

Affirms

Sexual sins are not categorically graver than other sins and should not be singled out for special emphasis or discipline.

Rejects

The unitive good (companionship, mutual love, and one-flesh union of the spouses) is at least as central as procreation, if not more so.

Affirms

Severe abuse (physical, emotional, or sexual) is itself a legitimate ground for divorce.

Rejects

Old Testament polygamy was genuinely permitted/tolerated by God for that era, not merely recorded as sin.

Rejects

It is acceptable for a Christian to marry a non-Christian (or to marry across major faith lines).

Rejects

The existence of intersex conditions shows that biological sex is not strictly binary and warrants pastoral and theological nuance.

Rejects

Marriage and child-rearing are the normative, expected path for most adult Christians.

Rejects

There are no grounds whatsoever that morally justify divorce for a believer.

Affirms

Pornography is wrong primarily because of exploitation/objectification and harm in its production, more than because of private lust.

Rejects

Couples should welcome as many children as God gives and not deliberately limit family size ("quiverfull" conviction).

Leans toward affirming

Sexual orientation can be substantially changed through prayer, therapy, or sanctification, and pursuing such change is appropriate.

Leans toward rejecting
Society & politics65 positions · 19 held strongly

Political life should be ordered toward a shared "common good" that the state has positive responsibility to promote, not merely the protection of individual rights.

Strongly affirms

A war may be just only if it meets defined criteria (just cause, legitimate authority, right intention, last resort, proportionality, reasonable hope, discrimination/non-combatant immunity).

Strongly affirms

A natural moral law, knowable in principle by reason apart from special revelation, is a legitimate basis for civil law and public argument.

Strongly affirms

The right to private property is conditioned by a duty to the common good, so that goods are meant to serve all and surplus wealth is owed to the needy.

Strongly affirms

Racism (partiality and contempt on the basis of race or ethnicity) is a sin contrary to the gospel.

Strongly affirms

Social problems should be addressed at the most local competent level, with higher authorities intervening only when lower ones cannot cope (subsidiarity).

Strongly affirms

Giving to the poor is a binding moral obligation, not optional charity, and to withhold from the needy is a sin.

Strongly affirms

Active civic participation (voting, advocacy, holding office) is a positive Christian duty in a free society.

Strongly affirms

The church is called to confront and change unjust social structures (economic, racial, political), not only to convert and disciple individuals.

Strongly affirms

Civil government is divinely instituted, and obedience to lawful authority is a Christian duty (Romans 13).

Strongly affirms

Caring for the natural environment is a genuine Christian moral responsibility flowing from the call to steward creation.

Strongly affirms

The civil law should impose the death penalty for a wide range of offenses specified in the Mosaic law (e.g. blasphemy, adultery, idolatry, sabbath-breaking).

Strongly rejects

The civil magistrate rightly holds authority over the external governance of the church (appointments, councils, discipline of clergy).

Strongly rejects

God ordains distinct nations/ethnic groups with boundaries that should be preserved, such that ethnic separateness has positive theological warrant.

Strongly rejects

It can be morally legitimate for Christians to use lethal force under some circumstances (e.g. defense of the innocent, just war).

Strongly affirms

God wills material prosperity and physical health for faithful believers, and these can be claimed through faith and giving.

Strongly rejects

Opposing abortion and protecting unborn life should be among the highest priorities of Christian political engagement.

Strongly affirms

Christians are bound by a real obligation of solidarity with the poor and oppressed, such that their interests have a privileged claim ("preferential option for the poor").

Strongly affirms

Scripture's command to welcome the foreigner and care for the sojourner imposes a real Christian duty toward immigrants and refugees today. (This question does not consider any political orientation's specific definition of what constitutes a legitimate "immigrant" or "refugee.")

Strongly affirms

Christ's lordship extends over every sphere of life (politics, economics, art, science) and Christians are called to bring all of them under his rule.

Affirms

Refusing military service as a conscientious objector is a legitimate, even commendable, Christian stance.

Affirms

It is fitting for Christians to seek and hold civil office in order to govern justly.

Affirms

Addressing systemic and structural racial injustice (not only individual prejudice) is a necessary part of the church's mission.

Affirms

The faithful church should largely withdraw from seeking or wielding state power, bearing witness as a distinct community rather than governing.

Rejects

Christians may, and sometimes must, disobey civil laws that command sin or are gravely unjust.

Affirms

Responding to human-caused climate change is a pressing moral and justice issue the church must actively address.

Affirms

Political compromise and coalition with non-Christians or ideological opponents is a legitimate and prudent way to pursue the common good.

Affirms

Faithfulness requires a "consistent life ethic" opposing abortion, capital punishment, euthanasia, and unjust war together as a single seamless garment.

Affirms

The gospel is essentially a message of individual reconciliation with God, and social transformation is at most a secondary by-product, not part of its core content.

Rejects

God may sanction war as a holy or sacred cause, such that fighting it is itself an act of religious obedience or merit.

Rejects

Because this world is passing away and will be replaced, long-term stewardship of the earth is a lower priority than saving souls.

Rejects

Taking a solemn oath before lawful authority, calling God to witness the truth, is a permitted and even reverent act.

Affirms

Serving in the armed forces is an honorable Christian vocation.

Affirms

Animals and the rest of creation have value to God in themselves, not merely instrumental value for humans.

Affirms

Christians must not resist evildoers with force even in personal self-defense ("turn the other cheek" taken as a binding command, not counsel).

Rejects

Nonviolence is the normative Christian way, binding on all believers, not merely a special vocation.

Rejects

Police work, including the use of coercive force to maintain order, is a legitimate Christian calling.

Affirms

The state should provide a fair, level public space for diverse religious and worldview communities rather than privileging Christianity or enforcing secularism.

Affirms

Private ownership of property is a God-given right that the state and church must respect and protect.

Affirms

Scripture provides binding, authoritative norms not only for personal conduct but for the ordering of society, economics, and the state.

Affirms

Government provision for the poor (welfare, public healthcare, social insurance) is a legitimate and good way for a society to fulfill its duty to the needy.

Affirms

Christians must not swear oaths at all (taking "swear not at all" as a binding command), affirming with a simple yes or no instead.

Rejects

The civil and judicial laws of the Old Testament (with their penalties) remain the standard for modern civil government.

Rejects

The present political and economic order is so fallen that the church should expect to witness against it rather than reform it, awaiting God's kingdom rather than building it.

Rejects

Voluntary poverty or radical simplicity is a holier and more Christlike way of life, to be honored above the pursuit of wealth.

Affirms

Christians should actively resist injustice through nonviolent means (protest, civil disobedience, noncooperation), not merely abstain from violence.

Affirms

The civil authority may rightly execute criminals for grave crimes.

Rejects

Capitalism as a system is intrinsically exploitative and stands under God's judgment; Christian faithfulness requires working to replace it.

Rejects

Some form of socialism or collective ownership is the most faithful social application of the gospel.

Rejects

Democratic, representative government is the political order most consonant with Christian convictions about human dignity and the limits of power.

Affirms

The ideal economy is one of widely distributed small-scale ownership (family farms, small businesses, cooperatives), avoiding both big-capital and big-state concentration.

Affirms

The dominion mandate means the earth's resources are given chiefly for human use and development, and exploiting them for human flourishing is good.

Rejects

Choosing between economic systems is a prudential, political matter outside the church's proper teaching authority; the church should not endorse capitalism or socialism.

Rejects

New Testament giving is freewill, proportional, and cheerful, without a binding fixed percentage like the tithe.

Affirms

A nation should publicly identify as Christian and order its laws, symbols, and institutions around the Christian faith ("Christian nation").

Rejects

A nation has a legitimate, God-permitted right to regulate its borders and limit immigration for the sake of order and the common good.

Affirms

Political and material success (electoral wins, national prosperity, victory) can be read as signs of God's blessing on a cause or nation.

Rejects

The Christian's energy belongs primarily in personal holiness, evangelism, and the life to come rather than in political reform.

Rejects

Civil law should reflect and enforce Christian moral standards on public matters (e.g. blasphemy, sabbath, vice), not merely a minimal shared morality.

Rejects

Christians are obligated to give a tithe (a tenth of income) to God's work as a binding standard.

Rejects

Lending money at interest (usury) is morally suspect or wrong, at least in its exploitative forms.

Affirms

Riches are inherently spiritually perilous, and the accumulation of wealth is a grave temptation the Christian should actively resist.

Affirms

A free-market economy is the most just and morally sound economic order, broadly compatible with biblical principles.

Leans toward rejecting

God acts in history specifically on the side of the oppressed against their oppressors, and the church's calling is to join that liberating work.

Leans toward affirming

The civil government has a duty to recognize, establish, and protect the true religion (and may restrain public false worship).

Leans toward rejecting
Angels & demons69 positions · 46 held strongly

The fall of the rebel angels was a single, definitive, irrevocable choice (no second chance, no repentance possible).

Strongly affirms

Angels are created beings, made by God, and are not eternal or self-existent.

Strongly affirms

Angels, once created, do not die and are by nature immortal.

Strongly affirms

Angels possess intellect and will: they know, choose, and act as persons.

Strongly affirms

Angels are purely spiritual (incorporeal) beings without material bodies of their own.

Strongly affirms

Biblical "angels" are best understood as symbols, personifications, or mythological language for God's action and human experience, not as actually existing spirit-persons.

Strongly rejects

Angels are real, personal, created beings who actually exist, not merely literary symbols or pre-scientific imagery.

Strongly affirms

Seeking contact with spirits/the dead through mediums, séances, channeling, or divination is forbidden and dangerous (opens to the demonic).

Strongly affirms

Apparent possession should be carefully screened against psychological and medical explanations before any exorcism is considered.

Strongly affirms

Demons are real, personal evil spirits (fallen angels or their kind), not merely symbols of disease, vice, or social evil.

Strongly affirms

The devil and his angels will suffer eternal, conscious punishment in the lake of fire.

Strongly affirms

The final fate of the devil and demons is destruction/annihilation (ceasing to exist), not unending conscious torment.

Strongly rejects

Every individual human being is assigned a personal guardian angel.

Strongly affirms

Evil is grounded in an eternal, uncreated power or principle opposed to God (cosmic dualism), not merely a corrupted creature.

Strongly rejects

Formal exorcism/deliverance is largely obsolete and unnecessary for the church today.

Strongly rejects

In the end even Satan and the fallen angels will be reconciled to God (apokatastasis of all rational creatures).

Strongly rejects

Exorcism should normally be performed through a formal, authorized rite by a duly appointed minister/priest, with ecclesial oversight.

Strongly affirms

Invoking angels by name in ritual/amuletic/"angelic magic" contexts to obtain power or protection is legitimate Christian practice.

Strongly rejects

Michael is a created archangel, a distinct being who is not the pre-incarnate Christ.

Strongly affirms

Satan is a fallen angel (a created good being who rebelled) not an independent evil principle or co-eternal power.

Strongly affirms

Satan/the devil is a real, personal spirit-being, not merely a symbol or personification of evil.

Strongly affirms

"Satan" is best understood as a personification of evil, temptation, or the human sinful inclination, not a literal spirit-person.

Strongly rejects

A portion of the angels rebelled against God and fell from their original state.

Strongly affirms

Worship (latria) of angels is forbidden; worship is due to God alone.

Strongly affirms

The angels fell primarily through pride: refusing subjection to God / seeking to exalt themselves.

Strongly affirms

The angelic rebellion occurred before the fall of humanity, and the serpent's temptation issued from an already-fallen angel.

Strongly affirms

There are genuine ranks or orders among angels (a real hierarchy), not merely undifferentiated spirits.

Strongly affirms

Beliefs about angels and demons should be limited to what Scripture plainly teaches, rejecting speculative hierarchies, named extra-biblical angels, and elaborate demonologies.

Strongly rejects

Angels are without sex/gender and do not marry or reproduce.

Strongly affirms

Angels exist in vast, possibly innumerable, multitudes.

Strongly affirms

Angels can assume visible, bodily appearances to interact with humans.

Strongly affirms

Angels are assigned specific offices and missions (messengers, guardians, ministers of providence, executors of judgment).

Strongly affirms

Angels possess some kind of refined, ethereal, or subtle body rather than being wholly immaterial.

Strongly rejects

Specific archangels (e.g., Michael, Gabriel, Raphael) are named and venerated/honored as distinct individuals.

Strongly affirms

1 Enoch (the Watchers material) carries real authority or reliable insight for understanding angels, the fall, and demons.

Strongly rejects

Casting out demons is a normal ministry available to ordinary believers, exercised informally by command and prayer, not reserved to ordained exorcists.

Strongly rejects

A human being can be genuinely indwelt/controlled by a demon ("possession").

Strongly affirms

Fallen angels retain their natural angelic powers (intelligence, strength, mobility), now turned to evil ends.

Strongly affirms

It is proper to address, ask, or pray to one's guardian angel for protection and aid.

Strongly affirms

Guardian/ministering angels are given to serve believers (the elect/the church), not assigned universally to all persons.

Strongly rejects

The traditional ninefold scheme of angelic orders (seraphim, cherubim, thrones, dominions, virtues, powers, principalities, archangels, angels) reflects a real heavenly order.

Strongly affirms

What the New Testament calls "demon possession" is best explained today as illness, epilepsy, or mental-health conditions described in pre-scientific terms.

Strongly rejects

Satan is presently active in tempting, accusing, deceiving, and opposing the church and individuals.

Strongly affirms

Satan and the powers were decisively defeated and disarmed at the cross/resurrection (Christus Victor), even if final destruction awaits.

Strongly affirms

Satan operates only within limits God permits and is wholly subordinate to God's sovereignty (cf. Job).

Strongly affirms

Angels (and named archangels) may be venerated and honored (dulia) and asked to intercede, distinct from the worship due to God.

Strongly affirms

Angels continue to intervene visibly or tangibly in ordinary human affairs today (rescues, warnings, appearances).

Affirms

Demons are specifically the disembodied spirits of the dead nephilim (Watchers' offspring), distinct from the fallen angels themselves.

Rejects

Excessive preoccupation with demons, curses, and the occult is itself spiritually harmful and to be avoided (a sober, Christ-centered focus is preferred).

Affirms

Guardian/ministering angels accompany the soul at death and bear it toward God.

Affirms

There is a meaningful distinction between demonic "possession" (indwelling/control) and lesser "oppression"/influence from without.

Affirms

Satan rules a real organized kingdom/domain of darkness with subordinate evil powers.

Affirms

The "Lucifer"/"Day Star" of Isaiah 14 (and the king of Tyre in Ezekiel 28) refers, at least typologically, to Satan and his fall.

Affirms

The "sons of God" were the godly line of Seth, and the "daughters of men" the line of Cain: a human intermarriage, not angelic.

Affirms

Spiritual warfare is conducted chiefly through the "armor of God" (truth, faith, prayer, Scripture, and righteous living) rather than through techniques of binding, rebuking, or mapping spirits.

Affirms

The decisive angelic fall (or a major one) occurred when the "sons of God" lusted after and mated with human women (Genesis 6 / the Watchers).

Rejects

Angels were created before (or at the very beginning of) the material cosmos.

Affirms

Angelology and demonology are peripheral matters that should occupy little doctrinal or practical attention.

Rejects

Overt demonic activity (manifestations, possession) is genuinely rare in ordinary modern Western life, even if real elsewhere.

Affirms

Pagan idols and false religions are, in some real sense, fronts for demonic powers (cf. "what pagans sacrifice they offer to demons").

Affirms

Believers have delegated authority to verbally "bind," "rebuke," and command demons in Jesus' name.

Rejects

The Genesis 6 episode is a key cause of the Flood and the origin of demons/unclean spirits in the world.

Rejects

Particular angels are assigned over nations or peoples (e.g., the "princes" of Daniel; an angel of a nation).

Affirms

Satan is presently bound/restrained in a decisive way (the Revelation-20 binding is a current reality limiting his power).

Affirms

The "sons of God" of Genesis 6 were fallen angels (Watchers) who took human wives.

Rejects

Specific high-ranking demonic powers ("territorial spirits") hold dominion over geographic regions, cities, or nations and must be discerned and confronted.

Rejects

Demons can directly cause physical illness, calamity, or misfortune.

Leans toward affirming

In deliverance, it is important to discern, name, and address individual demons (and their hierarchies/strongman) to expel them effectively.

Leans toward affirming

There are seven chief angels/archangels who stand before God (the "seven spirits/angels" tradition, including names like Uriel, Selaphiel, etc.).

Leans toward affirming
Anthropology65 positions · 48 held strongly

The material human body is intrinsically good as created by God.

Strongly affirms

The resurrection body will be materially/physically continuous in some real way with the present body.

Strongly affirms

Lifelong celibacy is a fully honorable and complete form of Christian human flourishing, not a deficient state.

Strongly affirms

Disordered desire (concupiscence) that remains in the baptized/regenerate is itself truly sin, not merely a tendency toward sin.

Strongly rejects

Human dignity does not depend on possessing or exercising any particular capacity (such as rationality or productivity).

Strongly affirms

Persons with severe cognitive or physical disabilities bear the full image of God and possess full personhood.

Strongly affirms

A dying, comatose, or severely declined person retains full human dignity and personhood until natural death.

Strongly affirms

All human beings possess equal intrinsic worth before God regardless of race, sex, ability, or status.

Strongly affirms

Men and women are equally called to all roles and offices, with no role reserved by sex.

Strongly rejects

The Fall defaced or marred the image of God without erasing it.

Strongly affirms

The image of God is the ground of the inviolable dignity and worth of every human being.

Strongly affirms

Human beings are created in the image of God.

Strongly affirms

The image of God remains in every human being after the Fall, however damaged.

Strongly affirms

Between death and resurrection the person exists in a conscious intermediate state apart from the body.

Strongly affirms

Human personhood is acquired gradually through development rather than possessed fully from the start.

Strongly rejects

All ethnic groups descend from a common humanity and share one undivided nature, with no theological basis for racial hierarchy.

Strongly affirms

The ultimate hope for human persons is bodily resurrection, not merely the survival of a disembodied soul.

Strongly affirms

God created humanity as male and female, and this sexed binary is a good and intended feature of human nature.

Strongly affirms

God directly and specially creates each individual human soul (creationism of the soul).

Strongly affirms

The human soul is by nature immortal and continues to exist consciously after the death of the body.

Strongly affirms

Human souls existed before their embodiment in this earthly life.

Strongly rejects

Human souls pass through multiple successive earthly lives (reincarnation).

Strongly rejects

The dead are unconscious ("asleep") until the resurrection, with no conscious experience in between.

Strongly rejects

It can be good and faithful for a person to live in and (where desired) medically transition to a gender identity differing from their birth sex.

Strongly rejects

The unborn human being is a full person bearing the image of God from conception.

Strongly affirms

Human beings can, by their natural powers and without any special grace, fulfill God's commands and choose the good.

Strongly rejects

The body is essential to being a complete human person, not an accidental or dispensable container for the soul.

Strongly affirms

Humanity is commissioned to develop and steward creation's potential (the "cultural mandate") as part of its God-given purpose.

Strongly affirms

Human dominion over creation is a stewardship of care, not a license to exploit.

Strongly affirms

The soul is present from the moment of conception (immediate ensoulment).

Strongly affirms

God assigns men and women distinct and complementary roles in the home and church.

Strongly affirms

Gender is a social or self-determined identity that can be distinguished from, and may differ from, biological sex.

Strongly rejects

Adam and Eve were real, historical individuals who are the biological ancestors of all humanity.

Strongly affirms

Humanity differs from other animals in kind, not merely in degree.

Strongly affirms

The image of God belongs uniquely to humans and is not shared by non-human animals.

Strongly affirms

The image of God consists primarily in a substantive human capacity such as reason, intellect, or will.

Strongly affirms

Each individual human soul has supreme and incommensurable value to God.

Strongly affirms

Grace perfects and elevates a human nature that, though wounded, remains fundamentally oriented toward God.

Strongly affirms

The first humans were created in a state of original righteousness or holiness, not in moral neutrality or immaturity.

Strongly affirms

Human beings inherit a corrupted nature (original sin) from Adam, prior to and apart from any actual sins they commit.

Strongly affirms

A person's maleness or femaleness is essential to who they are and persists in some form into the resurrection life.

Strongly affirms

Human sexuality is a good gift of God within its proper bounds, not merely a concession to weakness.

Strongly affirms

Whatever we call the "soul" emerges from the organized functioning of the body and brain rather than being separately infused or transmitted.

Strongly rejects

The soul is transmitted from parents to child along with the body through ordinary generation (traducianism).

Strongly rejects

Human beings possess libertarian free will: a genuine ability to choose otherwise that is not determined by prior causes or by God.

Strongly affirms

The human person can take the first step toward God, with grace then assisting what the person has begun.

Strongly rejects

Salvation involves a genuine cooperation in which the human will actively works together with divine grace (synergism).

Strongly affirms

Work is part of God's good creational design for humanity, not merely a curse resulting from the Fall.

Strongly affirms

A human being is constituted of two distinct elements, a material body and an immaterial soul.

Affirms

The ultimate destiny of the human person is to share in the divine nature (deification/theosis).

Affirms

Human beings can have arisen through an evolutionary process while still being specially created bearers of God's image.

Affirms

The image of God is properly defined by Christ, the true image, with humanity imaging God by conformity to him.

Affirms

The image of God consists primarily in humanity's capacity for and existence in relationship (with God and others).

Affirms

To be a person is fundamentally to exist in relation and communion, modeled on the Trinity, not as an isolated individual.

Affirms

Every honest occupation can be a genuine divine calling, not only ordained or "sacred" work.

Affirms

Free choice (self-determination) is itself a constitutive feature of the image of God in humanity.

Affirms

God grants prevenient grace to all, restoring enough freedom for any person to respond to or resist the gospel.

Affirms

A human being is constituted of three distinct elements: body, soul, and spirit.

Rejects

The human being is a microcosm uniting the material and spiritual orders, serving as a bridge or priest of creation.

Affirms

Scripture distinguishes "image" (retained) from "likeness" (lost in the Fall and restored in Christ).

Affirms

Rest (Sabbath) is built into the created human design and is essential to human flourishing, not merely a legal requirement.

Affirms

Sin so pervades every faculty of fallen humanity that no part of human nature is untouched by its corruption (total depravity).

Rejects

Apart from divine grace, the fallen human will is in bondage and cannot choose saving good on its own.

Affirms

Human beings are at their core basically good, with sin being secondary, environmental, or correctable.

Leans toward rejecting

Humans bear not only a corrupted nature but also actual guilt for Adam's sin.

Leans toward affirming
Covenant, law & Israel43 positions · 35 held strongly

Believers are entirely free from the law's condemning function but remain under its directing function.

Strongly affirms

The ceremonial/cultic laws (sacrifices, dietary rules, festivals, purity codes) are fulfilled in Christ and no longer binding.

Strongly affirms

Christians are positively obligated to keep the Ten Commandments as a covenant rule.

Strongly affirms

The civil/judicial laws of Israel expired with the Old Testament nation and do not bind modern states except as their general equity informs justice.

Strongly affirms

The Old Testament clean/unclean food laws are no longer binding, and all foods are permitted.

Strongly affirms

Jewish people remain in a valid saving covenant through the Mosaic/Abrahamic covenant and need not come to faith in Jesus to be saved.

Strongly rejects

Followers of Jesus, at least those of Jewish background, should continue to observe the full Torah (dietary law, festivals, Sabbath, circumcision).

Strongly rejects

Gentile believers were never placed under the Mosaic law and are free from its specific obligations.

Strongly affirms

Because salvation is entirely by grace, the Christian is under no law and obedience to commands plays no necessary role in the believer's life.

Strongly rejects

The children of believers are included in the covenant community and are proper recipients of the covenant sign.

Strongly affirms

The Levitical sacrificial system has been permanently ended and fulfilled by the once-for-all sacrifice of Christ.

Strongly affirms

The moral law, summarized in the Ten Commandments, is perpetually binding on all people in all eras.

Strongly affirms

A natural moral law, knowable by reason and binding on all people, underlies and confirms the moral content of God's revealed law.

Strongly affirms

The New Covenant prophesied by Jeremiah has already been inaugurated by Christ and is in force for the church now.

Strongly affirms

Ongoing obedience to God's commands is the necessary evidence and fruit of genuine saving faith.

Strongly affirms

The God and Scriptures of the Old Testament are fully continuous and authoritative for Christians, not a lower or superseded revelation to be set aside.

Strongly affirms

Physical circumcision remains a required covenant obligation for the people of God (or at least for Jewish believers).

Strongly rejects

The law has a positive "third use" as the normative guide for the grateful obedience of justified believers.

Strongly affirms

The Abrahamic covenant is foundational and its promises remain operative for the people of God today.

Strongly affirms

Baptism is the New Covenant counterpart to circumcision, marking entrance into the covenant community.

Strongly affirms

Members can break the covenant and forfeit covenant standing through unbelief or disobedience.

Strongly affirms

The New Covenant community is constituted by faith alone with no required physical entrance sign tied to covenant membership of households.

Strongly rejects

The Davidic covenant is being fulfilled now in Christ's present heavenly reign, not only in a future earthly throne in Jerusalem.

Strongly affirms

The biblical festivals (Passover, Pentecost, Tabernacles, etc.) should still be observed by believers.

Strongly rejects

There will be a future large-scale turning of ethnic Israel to Christ before the end ("all Israel will be saved").

Strongly affirms

A future earthly temple with a (memorial) sacrificial system will be established in a coming kingdom age.

Strongly rejects

Membership in the New Covenant consists only of regenerate, believing persons, with no "mixed" covenant community including unbelieving members.

Strongly rejects

The Noahic covenant grounds God's ongoing preservation of creation and a sphere of common grace/common order for all humanity.

Strongly affirms

Scripture unfolds a single, unified covenant of grace administered differently across redemptive history, so that Old and New Testament believers are saved in fundamentally the same way.

Strongly affirms

The law serves a civil/political use to restrain evil and preserve order in society generally, apart from salvation.

Strongly affirms

The biblical covenants (Noahic, Abrahamic, Mosaic, Davidic, New) progressively reveal and advance one connected divine plan that culminates in Christ.

Strongly affirms

The Sabbath obligation has been transferred to the first day of the week (the Lord's Day / Sunday) in commemoration of the resurrection.

Strongly affirms

The seventh-day (Saturday) Sabbath remains the divinely appointed day of rest and was never legitimately changed to Sunday.

Strongly rejects

The Mosaic law is rightly divided into moral, civil (judicial), and ceremonial categories, which have different applicability today.

Strongly affirms

God governs through two distinct kingdoms: the spiritual (church/gospel) and the civil (state/law/reason), which should not be collapsed into one another.

Strongly affirms

The church is the true and continuing Israel, having inherited the covenant promises so that ethnic/national Israel has no distinct remaining covenant role.

Affirms

Civil governments today are obligated to enforce the moral and judicial laws of Moses, including their penal sanctions.

Rejects

The gospel, properly defined, contains no commands or conditions; it is pure promise, and any imperative belongs to the category of law.

Rejects

Rightly dividing law from gospel (law as God's demand that condemns, gospel as God's gift that saves) is the central key to reading Scripture correctly.

Rejects

The church's mission includes progressively bringing every sphere of society under the lordship of Christ and biblical law.

Affirms

Humanity is organized under two federal heads, Adam and Christ, whose representative acts are imputed to those they represent.

Affirms

The Sabbath commandment is part of the perpetual moral law, requiring a weekly day of rest and worship for all believers.

Affirms

Proper Sabbath/Lord's Day observance forbids ordinary work and worldly recreation, devoting the whole day to worship and rest.

Rejects
Mary & the saints77 positions · 64 held strongly

Belief in Mary's assumption is a binding article of faith that must be held for full communion.

Strongly affirms

Mary was taken up body and soul into heavenly glory at the end of her earthly life.

Strongly affirms

The "brothers and sisters of the Lord" in the Gospels are Mary's biological children, born after Jesus.

Strongly rejects

Mary should be called only "mother of Christ" (Christotokos) / "mother of Jesus," and "Mother of God" is misleading or improper.

Strongly rejects

The Church has authority to formally declare particular departed persons to be saints in heaven (canonization).

Strongly affirms

The "communion of saints" is a living fellowship uniting believers on earth with the faithful departed in heaven.

Strongly affirms

The cult of the saints is a post-biblical accretion that should be removed rather than reformed.

Strongly rejects

Scripture itself warrants calling Mary "blessed" and honoring her as the favored mother of the Lord.

Strongly affirms

Mary is owed a special degree of veneration (hyperdulia) higher than that given any other saint, yet still infinitely below the worship due God.

Strongly affirms

Mary was preserved free from the stain of original sin from the very first moment of her own conception.

Strongly affirms

Invoking or praying to saints/Mary is forbidden: a form of necromancy or misdirected worship.

Strongly rejects

Adoration/worship (latria) is owed to God alone and may never be offered to any creature, including Mary or the saints.

Strongly affirms

It is fitting to keep a calendar of saints' feast days and commemorate them in worship.

Strongly affirms

Marian veneration is essentially a Christianized survival of pagan mother-goddess worship.

Strongly rejects

Mary cooperated uniquely and subordinately in the work of redemption such that she may be called "Co-Redemptrix."

Strongly rejects

Mary committed no actual personal sin during her life.

Strongly affirms

Mary occupies a quasi-divine or near-divine status, effectively a fourth person to be adored alongside the Trinity.

Strongly rejects

Mary was free from concupiscence (the inner inclination to sin), not merely from sinful acts.

Strongly affirms

After bearing Jesus, Mary was an ordinary believer with no continuing special status or role.

Strongly rejects

Mary is rightly honored as "Mother of the Church," the spiritual mother of all believers.

Strongly affirms

Mary herself needed and received salvation through Christ, like every other human being.

Strongly affirms

Mary is the "New Eve" whose obedience reverses the disobedience of the first Eve in the economy of salvation.

Strongly affirms

Mary was supremely holy and purified by grace, but was not preserved from original sin from conception in the Western "immaculate" sense.

Strongly rejects

Mary now reigns as Queen of Heaven, crowned and exalted above all the angels and saints.

Strongly affirms

Offering the Mass/Divine Liturgy for a specific deceased person confers real spiritual benefit on that soul.

Strongly affirms

It is wrong to make any pictorial representation of Christ or God at all (the regulative reading of the Second Commandment).

Strongly rejects

Prayer for the dead is right, but the Latin doctrine of purgatory as a defined place/process of satisfactory punishment should be rejected.

Strongly rejects

It is proper to assign patron saints to nations, occupations, and life-situations and to seek their particular patronage.

Strongly affirms

Mary remained a virgin even in the act of giving birth (her virginity was preserved "in partu"), without the ordinary physical changes of childbirth.

Strongly affirms

Mary remained a virgin throughout her whole life and never had marital relations or other children after Jesus ("ever-virgin").

Strongly affirms

Prayers may be addressed directly to saints and to Mary (e.g., "Holy Mary, pray for us"), not only to God.

Strongly affirms

The prayers, almsgiving, and Masses of the living can actually benefit and assist the departed.

Strongly affirms

It is right and beneficial to pray for the souls of the faithful departed.

Strongly affirms

Even genuine apparitions and private revelations add nothing to public revelation and bind no one's faith.

Strongly affirms

There is an intermediate state of purification (purgatory) in which the saved are cleansed before entering full glory.

Strongly affirms

The physical relics of saints (bones, possessions) may rightly be honored and venerated.

Strongly affirms

Repeated Marian devotions such as the Rosary are a wholesome and recommended form of prayer.

Strongly affirms

The dead, including Mary and the saints, are unconscious ("asleep") until the resurrection and so cannot hear or intercede.

Strongly rejects

The departed saints in heaven are aware of and intercede in prayer for those still living on earth.

Strongly affirms

Creatures (Mary, the saints) can exercise a real but wholly subordinate, intercessory mediation that does not rival Christ's unique mediation.

Strongly affirms

Mary may rightly be called "Theotokos" / "Mother of God" (God-bearer) because the one she bore is truly God incarnate.

Strongly affirms

The Church exists in three states: militant (on earth), suffering (being purified), and triumphant (in glory), in active mutual communion.

Strongly affirms

There is a real and legitimate distinction between the worship (latria) owed to God alone and the veneration/honor (dulia) given to saints.

Strongly affirms

Whatever the theory, the actual veneration of Mary and the saints functions as idolatry and dishonors God.

Strongly rejects

Jesus was conceived by the Holy Spirit while Mary was a virgin, without a human father.

Strongly affirms

It is good and proper to ask Mary specifically to intercede for us with her Son.

Strongly affirms

It is good and proper to ask the saints in heaven to pray to God on our behalf.

Strongly affirms

It is fitting (or required) that altars contain the relics of saints.

Strongly affirms

The "brothers of the Lord" are kinsmen/cousins, not siblings or step-siblings (the Hieronymian view).

Strongly affirms

A formal canonization is an infallible declaration that the named person is in heaven.

Strongly affirms

Claimed post-apostolic apparitions and visions of Mary or saints are, as a class, not from God.

Strongly rejects

When the Church formally approves an apparition (e.g., as "worthy of belief"), the faithful may reasonably trust it.

Strongly affirms

The "communion of saints" refers to the fellowship of living believers with one another (and with God), not to interaction with the departed.

Strongly rejects

Consecrating oneself (or one's nation) to Mary / to her Immaculate Heart is a wholesome act of devotion.

Strongly affirms

The destruction or removal of religious images from worship spaces was a faithful purification, not a sin.

Strongly rejects

Sacred images and icons of Christ, Mary, and the saints may rightly be venerated (honored with bows, incense, kisses), the honor passing to the prototype.

Strongly affirms

Material things and holy persons (icons, relics, saints) are legitimate created channels of God's grace, not idols, because the incarnation sanctifies matter.

Strongly affirms

Mary has genuinely appeared to people in history (e.g., at recognized sites) and such apparitions can be authentic.

Strongly affirms

Devotion to Mary is a central and indispensable feature of authentic Christian spirituality.

Strongly affirms

Mary is fittingly typified by the Ark of the Covenant, the Burning Bush, and similar Old-Testament figures.

Strongly affirms

Taking the name of a saint at baptism/chrismation and looking to that saint as a special protector is a good practice.

Strongly affirms

God works miracles, healings, or graces through the relics of saints.

Strongly affirms

Three-dimensional statues of saints and Mary are an acceptable form of sacred art and devotion.

Strongly affirms

In practice, the honors given to Mary and the saints tend to obscure or compete with the unique glory of Christ.

Strongly rejects

Messages delivered in apparitions (warnings, devotions, consecrations) carry real doctrinal or devotional authority for the Church.

Rejects

Saints and Mary can themselves grant favors, protection, or healing, not merely relay requests to God.

Rejects

Veneration of saints and Marian devotion are matters of individual liberty: neither required nor forbidden.

Rejects

"Saints" in the New Testament sense means all believers, not a special canonized class.

Rejects

There is exactly one mediator between God and humanity (Jesus Christ) and no creature shares in that mediating office.

Rejects

Religious images may be used for instruction and decoration but must not be venerated or bowed to.

Rejects

The "brothers of the Lord" are most plausibly Joseph's children from a marriage before Mary (the Epiphanian view).

Rejects

The proliferation of Marian titles and devotions should be restrained to keep Christ central.

Rejects

Mary truly died (fell asleep) before being raised/assumed, rather than being taken up without dying.

Affirms

All graces from God are dispensed to humanity through Mary's mediation.

Affirms

The historic trafficking and multiplication of relics was a corrupting abuse to be rejected.

Affirms

Particular saints are especially efficacious for particular needs (e.g., a saint for lost objects, travel, illness).

Affirms

Icons are not mere art but genuine "windows" through which the faithful commune with the holy persons depicted.

Leans toward affirming

Positions are tradition-level defaults drawn from public confessional documents and reference works; individual congregations can and do differ. Comparison is about distance, not better or worse.

Books from this tradition

Well-known titles for understanding the Catholic tradition, chosen for accuracy, not sponsorship.

  • Catechism of the Catholic Church by Libreria Editrice VaticanaThe Church's own official summary of Catholic teaching, the reference behind every doctrine on this page. · Bookshop.org
  • Catholicism by Robert BarronA widely read modern tour of the Catholic faith by one of its best-known living communicators. · Bookshop.org
  • Introduction to Christianity by Joseph Ratzinger (Pope Benedict XVI)A modern classic on the Apostles' Creed from the theologian who became Benedict XVI. · Bookshop.org
  • Story of a Soul by Therese of LisieuxThe beloved autobiography behind the 'little way', among the most read Catholic devotionals ever. · Bookshop.org

Outbound shopping links may earn this site a commission at no extra cost to you. How affiliate links work here.

Study deeper

Well-regarded tools for going past summaries and into the sources themselves.

Bible Gateway PlusA full study library (commentaries, study Bibles, dictionaries) layered onto the free BibleGateway.Logos Bible SoftwareThe deep-study software used by pastors and scholars for original-language and commentary work.
Brazilian Catholic Apostolic Church (Duarte Costa lineage): beliefs and distinctives · WheatAndGoats